Episode 116 – Chip Mahan: “I Couldn’t Do the Big Bank Thing”
Subscribe to the Podcast:







Chip Mahan has built his career revolutionizing the banking industry. He founded and currently serves as CEO and chairman of Live Oak Bankshares, headquartered in Wilmington, NC. Its commercial banking subsidiary, Live Oak Bank, specializes in providing lending and deposit services to small businesses nationwide. Chip joins us on the Faith Driven Investor Podcast to talk more about investing in technology that helps banks of all sizes innovate and cut through the red tape.
All opinions expressed on this podcast, including the team and guests, are solely their opinions. Host and guests may maintain positions in the companies and securities discussed. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as specific investment advice for any individual or organization.
Episode Transcript
Transcription is done by an AI software. While technology is an incredible tool to automate this process, there will be misspellings and typos that might accompany it. Please keep that in mind as you work through it.
John Coleman: Welcome back to the Faith Driven Investor podcast. This is John Coleman and I’m here with my partner Luke Roush in beautiful Wilmington, North Carolina.
Luke Roush: We are on the campus of Live Oak Bank, which is quite the place and it’s great to be back in North Carolina.
John Coleman: Absolutely. And we are privileged to have with us the founder of Live Oak Bank, Chip Mahan, who’s going to talk to us today about his story and about the variety of businesses he’s had the opportunity to kind of create and steward over the course of his lifetime. And the way that that intersects with a view of investing, I think that’s different than normal. So, Chip, thank you so much for being here today.
Chip Mahan: Delighted to be with you guys. It’s been fun so far for sure.
John Coleman: Well, maybe if you don’t mind just to get us started, tell us a little more of your personal story and how you came to found Live Oak Bank.
Chip Mahan: Well, I think, you know, to begin from the beginning and you guys cut me off about ramble too much, right? So an interesting turning point in my life was September the fourth, 1962. It was the first day of the sixth grade in Orchard Park, New York. And my dad worked for a oil company, the Ashland Oil Company in Ashland Kentucky. And regrettably, 13 men died on a company plane crash that night. and I’ll never forget. So my next door neighbor our next door neighbor was a senior executive at American Airlines. And I remember him poking me on the chest as my mother told us what happened that night and said, you know, now you’re the man of the house, which you’re 11 years old. Right. Like, ma’am. So my mother would tell you that that was a bit of a change. Apparently, prior to that, I was just kind of a happy go lucky little kid and then became maybe a little bit different after that moving forward, which also has to do with faith is. So we had to move back to the family farm at Frankfort, Kentucky. My grandparents had a 300 acre soybeans, corn, a few cows, tobacco, kind of scrub family farm. So my brother, my mother and I moved into that house, which was 800 square feet. Wow. And went to church that first Sunday. And I met a girl named Peggy […], whose father was in the civil engineering business. And we were 14 and high school our wrote in her capital in high school yearbooks that I was going to marry her. And she went to Highland college.
John Coleman: Did she know that prior to that point?
Chip Mahan: Yes, she did. She went to Highlands College in Roanoke, Virginia, I went to Wesley university in Lexington, Virginia, 45 minutes away. Yeah, I did marry her two weeks after college in 1973, and she has been the beacon of my life and ups and downs, a devout, great Christian.
John Coleman: Next year, 50 years.
Chip Mahan: Next year, 50 years, 50 years together.
John Coleman: Amazing.
Chip Mahan: Really more than that. So she turned 71 on May 5th last week. I’ll be 71 on May 26. Married a younger woman. So you really need to go back to 11, right? So it’s been 60 years, right? And, you know, we’ll talk business, all that kind of stuff. But at the end of the day, if you’re an entrepreneur, there are going to be ups and downs and the downs can be tough if you are not. What’s the purpose of this podcast? It’s all about. When you focus on Him and your life is dedicated to him. None of those things mean anything. Yeah, you go right to sleep. People ask you, what is your worst day? Everything that we do is for him. None of this is ours. You guys know that, right? The money, the stock, the equity. If you can just build something in his honor, then great things just actually happen. And then, you know, back to all that other mess, right? So I went to work at the Wachovia Bank when I was 22. The two presidents of the fraternity before me went to the training program. So I did that for a while. And then, you know, at some point life you got to decide you want to be an employee or do you want to be an owner? So I decided at 28 I wanted to be an owner, and that led to going to work for a guy in Lexington, Kentucky, who had bought a bank that was in serious trouble. It was actually bankrupt. Bankrupt the butcher, the brothers of Tennessee, Jake and C.H. Butcher. And that’s a whole another story. I got ran for governor, but so we took the bank. He hired me to run the bank, and then he ran out of money. So Saturday was the Kentucky Derby, a very exciting country derby.
Luke Roush: What a year.
Chip Mahan: This year I was something like 81. So Mickey Taylor was a lumberjack from Yakima, Washington. Jim Hill was a veterinarian from Miami Lakes, Florida, and they bought a racehorse for $17,000 by the name of Seattle Slew. Wow. And he won the Triple Crown. Wow. And when you syndicate a stallion, there are always 40 shares do know why. Those are the facts. So they kept on usually 20 to 40 shares. Wow. So I wanted to buy the bank. From this guy that was in trouble and I had no money. But since my father was a veterinarian and knew Dr. Hill, I was able to meet with Dr. Hill and Mr. Taylor. So I’ll remind you that at that time they were breeding that racehorse about a hundred times a year. So 22/40. Times 100 times $750,000. No laugh, old guarantee. So if you brought your may Seattle Slew, that’s an aging machine.
John Coleman: That is. So that’s a new fun strategy right there.
Chip Mahan: That’s what that is. So they staked us. We borrowed money against our houses and put up not much money. We had 25% of the bank and then all the banking laws changed. So you could now buy banks across state lines. So Bank one corporation and John Lacroix came to us before we actually closed. Wanted to buy that bank. Wow. So they bought the bank from us. And I’ll never forget having a conversation with him about no contracts. So we don’t believe in contract. So about two years into another, oh I can’t do this for the rest of my life? So what took the profits from that? Started our own banking company. So we bought banks in the middle of nowhere. Kentucky, very highly capitalized banks, a lot of core deposits, but no loans. That our thesis was to start banks in Lexington and Lowell make the loans in the city deposits in the country. And it worked out pretty well. And then in 1993, my brother in law, who had a security software firm in Atlanta, said to me over multiple glasses of wine one night, the Internet is going to be a big deal. I had no idea what the Internet was. I said, Why don’t we advertise CDs and savings accounts on this Internet thing to see if we can generate core deposits? And he said, You’re an idiot. We ought to put clicking on the web.
Luke Roush: What year is.
Chip Mahan: 1993? Wow. And. Okay, great. What’s Quicken? I want Quicken Loans. So this is this actually this kind of interesting thing. I said, okay, because he was kind of a genius. Stay at home guy. Got out of bed at 1030 in the morning right here. Puts where’s all this? It’s all happening. San Francisco, Palo Alto. All right, let’s go. Let’s get on a plane. Let’s go out there. So we met with Marc Andreessen.
John Coleman: In 93.
Chip Mahan: When the browser was Mosaic. Wow.
Luke Roush: And you are pretty old and all that.
Chip Mahan: And so they had just hired Jim Barksdale, who was the chief operating officer of FedEx, to run Netscape. So they changed Mosaic to Netscape. And he said, We’ll build that Internet bank for you. And said, what was going to cost? And he said, a million bucks. Then I got in a car with my brother in law. I said, That’s great, let’s get them to do that. He said, No, they want the source code. I said, What is source code, I do not know what source code was? And he said, I’ll do it for you. So we ended up. I moved from Lexington, Kentucky to Atlanta with my brother in law. He and his engineers built the first bank on the Internet, which was Security First Network. Wow. We beat Wells Fargo Market by month in October of 1994, I believe 1995. And it was a stock market, darling. I mean, we had a market cap of like six or $7 billion. Wow. And then one turning point, back to your comment about the way you run your businesses capital we kept saying that your capital is king. So I was sitting on the runway in 1999, I think it was before the crash in 98, May in Atlanta. And we were number 31 for takeoff. And the value of our business was in excess of Delta Airlines. Wow. I was flying to Amsterdam to meet with the number two guy at the ABN Amro Bank to sell software and Schiphol Airport, Amsterdam. Beautiful, beautiful place flying there. All the flowers in the tubes. Right. And so we met in a conference room there, and I was getting on the airplane, the same airplane once they cleaned it to go back. So I flew over for just 2 hours. And I got to thinking about that, like, this is wrong. I mean, we’re losing large amounts of money. We need to raise more capital. So I called the board from the airport and said, I want to raise $300 million from our customers.
John Coleman: What year was this?
Chip Mahan: This was 98 99 before the crash. So my brother in law and I went to State Farm in the early days, said you ought to have it back. So I did the State Farm Bank to these $20 billion bank. And we did a lot of work with them. So I called them and they wrote a check for 100. Zurich Insurance was their customer. They wrote a check for 75. Wow. This collision, I like to say I never know about life and where it’s going. Brian Moynihan was general counsel at Fleet Bank and he was a big fan of ours. He wrote a check. He’s now the chief executive officer of the Bank of America. Right. So had we not raised that capital, that $300 million, I don’t think that company would have made it. And that’s a little bit of a reflection of this bank. We have probably the highest capital ratio of any bank in the country. We really peel the Union Bank and see the amount of capital that we have versus the risk that we’re taking, because most of our loans are guaranteed by the United States government. And then, you know, it’s like my wife is like the most unbelievable human. You know, anytime you come up with an idea, you know, let’s sit down and talk about […]. Legal […]. Yeah, right.
John Coleman: Yeah.
Chip Mahan: And the things I heard, you guys probably […] tear it up throw it into the trash. You know, I couldn’t live with myself, if we don’t try.
John Coleman: Yeah, that’s right.
Chip Mahan: And she always says, How long do I have? And where are we going? Yeah, well, we’re moving from Lexington to Atlanta. from Atlanta to […] And she literally, you know, she live in a mobile home. Right. So when you have faith in him and you have a spouse like that and you think about the journey of life in general. Like it doesn’t get any better than that and you just spend time with my daughter. So she certainly reflects her most.
Luke Roush: Extraordinary, you.
Chip Mahan: So anyway, like I told you, I was going to ramble too much because.
Luke Roush: I want to take a little detour, I want to get back to your decision because. So when we pulled into the parking garage this morning, I was quote, over top. And when you say you flew to Amsterdam and back for like a two hour meeting that says something, but like do you do that often? Get on a plane for an hour, a two hours meeting, come back and maybe just dovetail that into what it says in that parking garage?
Chip Mahan: Yes. I mean, that’s why I’m so blessed to have people like [..] that you met earlier that can deal with regulators and compliance and all those things that are not fun. What’s the most fun for me to get on a plane without having to go see a customer and see if we can do some business together? Right. And I think, you know, it’s a little bit like sports. I mean, you guys probably played sports, you know, a hundred years ago. I played basketball. And it’s like you can say you hustle and you can say you are pretty good at customer service. But did you did you treat that customer like the only customer in the bank? Yeah. So when you put your head on the pillow at night, did you give it your all? So the basketball analogy would be it’s like you didn’t say it was like you’re under the basket and that dude elbows you in the jaw and now the adrenaline’s flowing out and you’re going down on the other end and you’re jumping as high as you jump. But maybe just the fingernail touched the ball that it allowed a teammate to tip it in at the buzzer. There’s that level of effort and it’s not. It’s binary. So if, in fact, everyone here has fun putting capital in the hands of small business America, which in my judgment have been a bit orphaned by our industry, I think the big banks do a wonderful job and retail and credit cards and all those sort of things. I think they do a fantastic job for the larger companies. I do not think they do a very good job for a 35 year old female veterinarian who happened to break her arm. And she’s a single mom. And are you going to do everything you can to help her staying in her business? Because she really didn’t have the right disability insurance or there’s construction in front of her place. So we have built probably 100 websites for veterinarians. We go to 450 trade shows a year to say to that industry and to those people. We are here for you. And when you’re young people, you know, sitting behind me here are 55, 22 year olds that are responsible, giving a financial statement every 90 days on 5000 customers. If you love what you do, then you will treat every customer like the only customer. And I said earlier, I mean, you know, it’s kind of like the airline business. Remember couple of years ago, they punched that guy in United Airline.
John Coleman: Oh, yeah, yeah. Oh, yeah.
Chip Mahan: Like, what do you people do it? I mean, like the banking business is.
John Coleman: Well, they didn’t punch everybody, though, just out.
Chip Mahan: But it’s just like, you know, what do you do? You really care like and that’s right. I think by and large, that is the difference in this place.
John Coleman: Well, and that brings us to Live Oak. I mean, what I love about your story is there is this kind of glamorous sort of meaning marketing […]. And in 1993 and learning about the Internet and launching the first Internet bank and then with Live Oak, you almost went the other direction, which is to take an overlooked segment like veterinarians and begin to just dominate the way in which you work with them. Talk to us about that transition and founding this bank and the desire to work with small businesses in these overlooked niches.
Chip Mahan: Yeah, that’s a good question. So I think that if you ask most bankers historically, they would say the SBA division is more or less the portal out of the banking business. So if the commercial lending dudes can’t make a big time commercial loan, send it down to Mikey in the basement of the SBA […] And slap a government guarantee on credit. So that’s kind of what that was. But the interesting thing is that if you delve into that, as we did in the early days, if you understand that you can lend money to 1100 different industries, and then if you look as we did. In the early days of the Freedom of Information Act data and veterinarians pay their loans back. Chicken farmers pay their loan back. And you focus on different segments where you understand at least the historic payment records of every other bank in the country in the Portland Banking Department. And then if you add to that, the fact that we are going to hire a domain expert. Domain experts are pretty simple definitions, like if you run one of those businesses. So we would hire people like that. Put people like that on our board. An example of that, and I think it may be an interesting one, I believe perspective is the chicken business. So Dan Jackson’s a friend of mine.
Luke Roush: Not a hypothetical example. You guys are actually in chicken, but in business.
Chip Mahan: And I’m going to tell you why. And I think this would be a typical of other banks. Right. So Dan was the former COO of Foster Farms, a privately held company in California’s largest chicken business west of the Mississippi. He was also the CEO of Pilgrim’s Pride. So you see like. Tell me how the chicken business operates. And there was one bank in Eldorado, Arkansas, that did almost all the SBA loans. And Dan explain the business. Here’s how it works. You really need to have six chicken houses to make the numbers work. And this is where we got into the business for 2013, these chicken houses, 660 feet long, 66 feet wide. The big chicken companies are going to bring 42,000 chicks to each house. They’re going to bring you the feed and in 39 days if it’s a Chick-Fil-A chicken at four and a half pounds. They’re going to come pick up the birds and they’re going to send us the flock chick. So the grower. I either baby sitter at the birds. It’s his money after we get our money. And so what are the real risks? Generators, chip you need to […]. Most chicken houses are in the south. Georgia is a big state. You got a thunderstorm, everything goes out. Birds are dead in 30 minutes. Yeah, that’s it. So tell me about the first national […]. So, you know, they’re little white guys that are older, you know, 75% loan to value. So let me ask you a question. Like what happens if we loan to 100% or the two and a half million dollars to get started to a 28 year old guy are mostly guys, not gals really in this business that wants to be in the chicken business? What’s the debt service coverage ratio? 125 to 135. Done. Yeah. Let’s go do that. So we’ve loaned over $1,000,000,000 until the SBA changes over 10%, down to 28 year old guys. And hey, Howard, Georgia. So it all works. So Matt Anglin, which we have a video of, was one of our first customers. Veteran Iraq, Afghanistan, several tours was a welder, $35,000 a year. We now know he need money for his second set of houses. He makes $300,000 is a chicken farm. Yeah. And has something to give to his children. So I think, you know, if you think of that and then the other thing that we do that’s quite a bit different is this. I think it’s part of the culture, too. So. Every SBA lender in the country is paid the same. Typically. So if you make $1,000,000 loan, let’s use that example. You package up $750,000 for a bow tied around that package guaranteed by the government. Sell it a bank makes 75 grand, gives a third of that to the […] commission. Mm hmm. So we thought, like, how is that going to work? We going to pay? we have $25,000 day one on a 25 year chicken. Mm hmm. That are making sense to me, because if he’s trying to sell the credit guy, he sits at the door of the vault. Yep. And transfer that risk to him so he gets a check and the credit guy gets the risk. It’s like, man, this is a bank. Yeah, we can’t do that. Well. Okay. So that has a lot to do with the culture here. And when we hire other people from other banks. This is an interesting situation that is taking place beginning at 4:00 today. No name but an average SBA lender in this country does that 8 to $12 billion of loan production per year. Our guys do over 25. Wow. We are interviewing a guy this afternoon did 200.
John Coleman: 200 million? Wow
Chip Mahan: On commission. $2 million a year. Wow. That’s going to be an interesting negotiation, etc..
John Coleman: How do you. I mean, because what you describe, though, for those of us less familiar with banking. You’re describing an underwriting process that actually knows the industry and the counterparty better. And yet you’re also doing more volume. How does that work within the context of the bank to be able to do greater diligence and know it better, but also move greater volume?
Chip Mahan: Well, I think, you know, it does get back to shoot letter. It does get back to treating every customer like the only customer. It does get back to go into 450 trade shows a year. But it’s deja vu all over again. I mean […] I mean lending money to get there it’s not rocket science. It’s not like we’re lending to a multi national conglomerate. Right. It’s a services business. It’s $1 to $2 million revenue business. It’s not rocket science. We just do it again and again and again. And the same is true of most every industry. It doesn’t take that long to figure out the few home business. Right. So if you have the domain expertize and you have the right people and you have the technology to answer the question, as we discussed earlier, am I approved and when I’m going to get the money, it’s relatively simple, right? And I think the other thing that’s so different is if you think about the banking business, right, it’s usually a bank in a geographic area. So you have the bank of Wilmington in New Hanover County where they branches. Right. So you take deposits from the butcher, the baker, the candlestick maker, and you lend money to the same. And if things are going well in that geographic area, things are fine. Are they growing? Are they not fundamentally. Most banks or real estate play. And we basically said we’re not going to do that. I mean, it was hard to get this charter approved because if you think about the FDIC who writes the deposit insurance, they’re saying, let me see if I got this right. You’re going to start a bank in Wilmington and you’re not going to have branches now. We’re going to pay up for deposits. That’s not we don’t want proper deposits. And you’re only going to lend money to veterinarians. Yeah right don’t like concentration. That’s it. And you’re going to lend money all over America and not geographically to where you’re located. That’s right. We don’t like any of that. So it took us a long time to get that approval. So we got that approval on May 12, 2008. What happened in this time? You remember what happened in September? Yeah. Okay, great. So in March of 2009, the FDIC called me to Atlanta and I had Neil Underwood with me, who is a brilliant technologist, been with me since day one. He’s one of these guys who has to have instant feedback after every meeting, like, man, seriously on a 1 to 10, how did we do? So she looked me in the eye and let me describe banking regulators. They have a unique characteristic. They’re masters of the pregnant pause, which is what that was. And they don’t blink. They stare at you.
John Coleman: Yeah.
Luke Roush: It makes me uncomfortable. That’s even right now.
Chip Mahan: They just stare at you, and they don’t blink. And she looked me right in the eye and she said, Mr. Mahan, I want you to sell or liquidate this bank.
John Coleman: Wow. This is six, eight months after you founded it, basically.
Chip Mahan: Prior to that, we started Live Oak Lending Company. So under special approval by the SBA, you can start a lending company fundamentally a broker. So we had parked $140 million of pawns at a bank in Hendersonville, North Carolina, in anticipation of selling those loans. We got our charter and I told her, I said, No, ma’am, we can’t do that. We have commitments to $140 million worth […], primarily the female veterinarians. And you got to do what you gotta do. We got do what we got to do. And then we got in the car and Underwood said, Well, how do you think the meeting works? Like, what are you talking about?
John Coleman: What meeting were you in?
Chip Mahan: Well, what are you. What are you talking about? My gracious […] life. She told us to liquidate or sell the bank.
Luke Roush: So I said finish the story. Because, I mean, you know, the critics, right? Not in the arena, but the critic outside the arena would say, well, your NPL rate is going to be way high. I mean, you’re going to have all kinds of charge offs that concentrated, you know, goodness gracious, these people don’t have any assets. And that’s why they’re looking for an SBA. They don’t have any assets,.
Chip Mahan: That’s for sure.
Luke Roush: And how that turned out.
Chip Mahan: Our loss ratio over 13 years is 30 basis points. Wow. So Wells Fargo was historically the number one SBA lender for many, many years. Their losses were two and a half percent.
John Coleman: Wow.
Luke Roush: How has it been eating their lunch?
John Coleman: Well.
Chip Mahan: You know, look, here’s the deal on that, right? So Wells Fargo. I remember when Carl Reichert used to run that place and they had a great reputation and Kovacevich came in and they had a great reputation. And, you know, their challenges have been well documented. But of all the Wells Fargo lenders that we’ve hired here are just fundamentally, extremely well trained. Most of them have been with Wells for 20 plus years. Most have started in the branch and worked their way up and are just wonderful human being and just it broke their heart to leave. Right. They had the stagecoach coming out of their veins until the place just ran them up. And then fundamentally the regulators were running it, plants was running it, and it was just they couldn’t get an answer to their customers, which are paid on commission, and that’s where that goes. They had to do something else. Yeah.
John Coleman: Well, one I think one of the more fascinating aspects of your story and I want to come back to this scaling the client service mentality, because now the bank is publicly traded, $2 billion market cap. 800 people everywhere. It’s clearly outgrown just loaning to veterinarians. How do you scale that mentality that allowed you to succeed? So you obviously have it. You were probably able to hire a few people who had it at the beginning, just this dedication to that segment, a real purpose and meaning and serving them as you expand in the bank’s remit expands. How do you scale that culture of client experience or customer focus?
Chip Mahan: You know, that’s a good question. So I get asked that all the time, and I think I’d come back to this. Right. So the American banker has been around the magazine. They have been around since like 1837, and they do the best banks to work for every year. And we won it like four years in a row. So they would ask all of our employees 100 questions anonymously, and I’d be happy to give that to you guys. Okay, so we start the bank, we got eight employees, right? And we do the same thing and it goes to 50 and 50 goes to 100. And then we run into Evan, right? It’s like so every time you add another human being, you’ve got to be the same. And if you are hiring the right people that have the right heart and have the right desire to help the customer overwhelmingly set it right, there is three legs to this, that’s your customer. You have folks, you have the shareholder and you hire the right folks and you tell them what we talked about. Like seriously treat every customer like the only customer all day, every day less. But you get to do, what we got to do is do everything we can for you in every way. Yeah. So is that a nice place to work these buildings in this camp? Is it a 6% […] payment? Is it paying 100% of your health care? Is it have three jets that can go to the West Coast flying 800 hours a year with normal corporate travel? 300? Yeah. Is it? So in the early days, we think wellness is important. So I think what we’re going to buy a individual session for all of our people three days a week. So if you’re making 50 grand a year and you get a personal session one on one with a trainer, $60 each, 180 bucks after tax week, you’re making 50 grand a year. Let’s say you’re a closer. Toughest job on the bank. You got 148 documents for every SBA loan and you’re closing 12 deals all at wow. Lawyers, paralegals on both sides. I need the money, construction draws, all this kind of stuff. You might need an hour for yourself, but I want you to know that it’s not necessarily bad. What I want you to know is, like you are important to me. You are important to building that business. Not necessarily me and my role, but for us and our role, us meaning all of us. And if you do that right and you make it fun and every time, you know, as we discussed earlier, we invest in these companies. And so far, these companies have done well. And then when you make a profit and you sell those business and you let everybody participate the profits. We do that also in the early days before we were public or private, just I went to the board and Tim and I got all the data of every bank in North Carolina. In 2009, and only 5% made more than 10% on equity in that year. A lot of them off. We were making 35% on equity, 4% of assets on the board and said, look, here’s what I want to do. I want to do 10% return on equity, which is better than 95% of the banks in North Carolina. We get all the shareholders above that. Let’s give $0.25 of every dollar to our employees.
John Coleman: I love that.
Chip Mahan: Exclude the senior management team, all the original shareholders and just your one 55% of base.
John Coleman: Wow.
Chip Mahan: And after that, it was 33 and 18 and 33 until we were public. Kind of too hard to manage it that way. But again, it gets back to, you know, we talk about it, we talk about trust and we talk about love. If you love your folks, all of them, and you trust your folks, they’ll do the right thing. Yeah, they’ll take care of the customer. And here we go.
John Coleman: Maybe. Well, I was just going to pivot a bit because you know we’ve heard about chicken farms and veterinarians, but there is a secret about live open, about some of the work you do that you haven’t told us about, which is, I mean, you had incubated and launched a number of extraordinarily successful technology companies on the back of the bank and then have also invested in technology companies. Would you talk to us a little bit about that component of the work and where it started and how you manage those two things alongside each other? A very analog kind of old school banking business right alongside a very successful financial technology enterprise that you’re building.
Chip Mahan: Well, I think it kind of gets back to the story about my brother in law and how smart he was technology and how dumb I was. Right. So Neil Underwood’s been with me since the beginning, back during the S-1 days, and he is a technologist and he was working at S-1 at the time when I said, Neil, I need your help, but we’re trying to lend money in 50 states and we got 150 documents in this government guaranteed loan, and we’ve got a hand-off problem. So the lender, the architect of the deal that understands safety, soundness of debt service coverage ratios and understands all the nuances of the government guarantee 550 pages SOP, works with an underwriter, so they architect a deal. Now you got to get all the documents. Then you got to get it approved by the credit department, right? So you have an underwriter and then you got a closer. God love their soul. And that’s a huge challenge because you’re juggling all those things we talked about before. Well, then you got to service the long run. You got to get financial statements every 90 days. Are you doing what you said you were to do relative to the budget and all that? And how are we going to perfect that hand off? So back during our S-1 days, we had 650 folks in India. Mm hmm. And I spent some time over there. I know some of those fellows. So I called them and said, Can you help me this way? I flew over from India so we can build this. And that didn’t work out very well. And then Neil was still in Atlanta, the other company. I said, Neil I need some help on this. We got to scale this thing. So we had another guy from Atlanta who was a software architect. That didn’t go so well. I said, Neil, buddy, I’m serious about this. We got our fixes on the charts, graphs and flowcharts and all these sort of things. So he and his brother on one rainy weekend in December, interviewed a ton of different companies, and they picked Salesforce when Salesforce market cap was $2 billion. So we started writing code. And then another guy that worked at S-1 about the new appeared all day. They were in the process of selling that company, so we convinced Pierre to come run that business. And I said, This is great. And really what happened before? that was Neil sneaked off and made a presentation at the Mosconi Center in San Francisco at the annual Salesforce User Conference, where they fundamentally take over all of downtown that, you know. And it was in the financial services segment of the Salesforce.
John Coleman: Dreamforce, Dreamforce. He was doing that big deal.
Chip Mahan: And then he gets mobbed afterwards when he showed what we had already built at the bank and he Mahan Let’s go back in the software. I don’t want to back in the software business. It is just too hard. No, seriously Mahan. And this is different. This is cloud based. We can get this code, we spin up an org, we do this today. I said, All right, let’s just see if we can get a small bank to use it. And then they ran up to try to sell US bank. I said, It’s not going to go well. This is a nascent software company in Wilmington, North Carolina, inside a bank. They’re not going to fool with it. And they did. Right. And then one bank bought it another bank also. Look, we got to get this out of the bank because we’re a federally regulated bank with capital ratio challenges. So if you’re going to scale this, but it’s going to raise more capital. So we did. The rest is history.
Luke Roush: So, Chip, one of the things that you’ve talked about today is seeing a problem and then being able to step in and solve it with technology. And so nCino came out of that public company that has grown quite large. You made a bunch of investments, green light, fintech, others. Maybe just speak a little bit about how you’ve thought about active investing from the platform it’s been built in and through a lot of.
Chip Mahan: I think it goes back to, you know, the Force.com cloud based discussion. I mean, you know, the estimate is that there are 280 billion lines of code in the financial services business. And just having watched this over the years, I think it’s all going to get swamped out. Right. So a very well-known, unnamed banker recently, relatively recently, used the term cloud blast. Right. So if you think about all those companies that serve all the smaller banks in the country Foster, Jack Henry and I asked them lots of data centers. Yeah. So you’re going to be more efficient than Amazon Web Services, whose data centers run at 119. And yeah, go back and look, over the last ten years, how many banks, Internet banking systems have gone down? So if you think about the market cap of Amazon, Google and Microsoft who are dramatically trying to solve this problem, I mentioned this in the earnings call. I’ll scrub the numbers. I think in the last quarter, Microsoft made $17 billion on 49 billion in revenues for the quarter. They now own 20% of the cloud based business. Amazon Web Services owns 40. Yeah. And their business last quarter grew 46%. And I don’t know if you split out AWS and ran it as a separate company, you’d still be probably worth $1,000,000,000,000. Yeah, I know all stocks are all down a lot this is going on, but it’s like no individual bank is going to be more efficient in a cloud based environment than those three companies. And they’re making it better every day. Yep. So we started a company, to your point./Luke better go call payrails the next generation build peak company where you give the banks the data which currently competitors do not. So we have received 40 price decreases since we started that business. For me now, because more people that use the system, the more that they can improve the product. So when do you buy a product from a company and expect the price to go down next year?
Luke Roush: Maybe it doesn’t happen.
Chip Mahan: It just doesn’t happen. Amazing. Right. So that to me is pervasive. And so if we look at each little subsegment cybersecurity, defense store, bill pay, pay rails, internet banking, front end aperture, we’re moving everything as fast as we can to the cloud, much more efficient. And that gives you the ability to do other things like we’re doing at this company, which is if we’ve bundled together 14 separate vendors to get where we are at Lavo, can we sell those services to others? Other banks only branches, so we don’t have a teller application. So we’ve got to fill this out of that out. But I think we have the ability to do that over and over again.
John Coleman: And you’ve started to find effectively to support that model, correct?
Chip Mahan: Correct. So we made like six investments and in Lava Ventures at the Holding Company, but we’re a small bank, so, you know, we had a runway quickly there. So Gene Ludwig has been a friend of mine for years. Gene went to Yale Law School with the Clintons and President Clinton made him Comptroller of the Currency in 1992. He then started a consultancy called Promontory prior to the Great Recession. And of course, after 2008, every bank CEO was interested in talk, in the Gene, because he hired all the most senior regulators from every branch of the government, from the FDIC, even back in the ALTS days, to the LCC. And he built a very wonderful business there. And he came and sat in that chair one day and said, Let’s do a fund. Let’s do a venture capital fund to do this thing. He was a seed investor at […]. So he saw the power of the cloud nCino. You know, in the early days in Force.com an all of that. So we did we went out to 45 banks. That a simple thesis, as you could possibly imagine, to say, you know, we’ll be your venture capital arm. It’s all about looks at the basket because, you know, all these fintech companies that raise unlimited amount of capital, a low interest rate environment like nCino, did they know nCino is now doing $250 million in revenues, but still losing like $40 million a year where you can’t do that inside a bank holding company. But if you get many, many looks at the basket of companies like that, it would allow you to serve your customers better. That is the thesis of Canopy, right? So we raised $650 million from 45 banks we’re closing fund to which are probably 700 plus million dollars, maybe 50 banks this time. But if you were a white hot fintech entrepreneur in the Silicon Valley and you want to sell your software to a bank, it is highly likely you’re going to call us.
John Coleman: When.
Chip Mahan: We get a call Andreessen, Horowitz and Sequoia and all those big shots. But if you want customers, you’re probably going to call us. And, you know, so far so good. They’ve done quite well.
Luke Roush: Yeah. Maybe just speak to one of the things that many of the listeners of Faith Driven Investor and we’ve all talked about a lot is that at times the financial services sector has not earned a reputation of truth and transparency and real customer engagement and care. Maybe speak to your faith and how that affects the way you see yourself as a change agent in financial services across the breadth of how God is using you today.
Chip Mahan: Well, you know, I think that just gets back to our folks. I mean, I can’t speak for any other bank I, you know, as I mentioned earlier, Brian Moynihan is a good friend of mine. How in the world somebody runs the Bank of America is beyond me. He’s done a fantastic job with probably 300,000 employees or whatever they have today. But I think if we just stick to our knitting and maintain the culture that we have, caring about the customer and caring about each other. Right. I mean, treat folks the way you want to be treated. And, you know, it’s hard. And heaven knows, as we’ve had this conversation, it’s hard in a federally regulated institution from the FDIC to the SEC to the SBA to the state of North Carolina, and the SEC being a public company for me to preach. Right? Mm hmm. But every chance I get, I try to let our folks know that this is all because of him. Mm hmm. And Peggy and I feel that way about whatever capital we’ve developed there. We’re just going to make sure it all goes to him and do what he wants us to do to help those less fortunate. And I think that’s been, you know, our major focus in terms of education here in Wilmington. I know you talked to my daughter earlier about Glo. We went to New York City and met with the Tisch family seven years ago and they started a school for minorities in every minority on the planet is in New York City. And, you know, there are 100 girls in each class of 600 from sixth grade to 12th grade. And I was blown away that 100% graduated and 100% went to college. So we’re now in our sixth year here. And we’ll have our first graduating class here this year and hopefully can replicate that model. Now, that said, we uncovered a challenge here in Wilmington, North Carolina, with 125 thousand, who we get our girls in the sixth grade. They’re three grades behind. Mm hmm. So what are you going to do about that? Well, our research indicates that we probably need at least ten child care centers for six weeks to pre-K. Mm hmm. So Peggy and I have bought a building, renovating that building to take care of 180 kids. Wow. And then, as a quick aside, we live in. The most interesting place in the United States of America. We just sold here Wilmington, the largest private hospital in the United States. 4,000,000,006 billion; a billion four of the billion six sits in a foundation. Now, New Hanover County is a second smallest county in the state of North Carolina, and 100% of the investment proceeds need to be re channeled in New Hanover County. Wow. Wow. We have gone to them and said, we’ll pilot your riskier projects and if it works. So maybe we’ll do to our families. Then you come in behind that with that massive amount of capital you have and really, really help. You know, Wilmington, North Carolina, is no different than Nashville. It’s no different than Charlotte. I mean, we all have the same challenges and the poverty level and the crowds shootings and things like that. But we actually have a chance at a town this small with that and capital the no way solve it. You have to have the right people in these positions. And I know that you guys know Casey and you know what he’s doing with schools and you bet his team when you meet his team that is running that show, it’s like they’re going to win. Yeah, I don’t know how they’re going to win, but they’re going to win. they are driven driven people to educate those people. That to us is the answer. Well, I mean, I don’t know how many times in the Bible I you know, that I listen to Tim Keller every day of my life and I sit down every day listening Tim Keller’ sermon in the morning.wow. And his people will be here in this room Wednesday for lunch. Yeah. Yeah. I met him one day in a zoom call for about an hour and a half. But it’s like I’ve read every book that he’s written. He’s had a dramatic effect on the way.
Luke Roush: I think our co-founder Henry Kaestner would say the same thing about Tim’s teaching. He spoke at our annual meeting a couple of years ago when Extraordinary Guy got in.
Chip Mahan: He is a modern day C.S. Lewis period in the story. Full stop.
John Coleman: Well, Chip maybe they close us out. We do like to ask folks at the end of these conversations just what are you learning from scripture right now, potentially from the sermons you’re listening to, what God teaching you right now that you might want to share.
Chip Mahan: To help those children tell the children, to help the children. To help the children. And if we can help the children in Wilmington, if we could come up with a plan, then can that be scalable? Like everything else we’ve talked about the rest of the end of the day, it’s about if you’re not growing your diet. So it’s always about scaling the business. If we can scale like actually wants to do with the schools that he’s investing in that we maybe can have effect on those that can’t help themselves.
John Coleman: It’s a good word Chip. This was fascinating conversation all the way from your elementary middle school love story. I guess you’re working with Mark Andresen on Netscape and launching the first Internet bank to serving chicken farmers, now serving the educational community in Wilmington and beyond. We’re really grateful for the work you’re doing in the financial services sector and beyond, and also grateful for you for sharing this story with the listeners here at the Faith Driven Investor podcast. So thank you so much for come.
Chip Mahan: I’m honored. Yes, I’m truly.
Episode 101 – HOPE for Ukraine with Peter Greer
Subscribe to the Podcast:







HOPE International was founded in Ukraine 25 years ago. Since then, they’ve invested in the dreams of thousands of Ukrainian entrepreneurs and farmers. They’ve seen families work their way out of poverty and lives changed by the Gospel. HOPE International President and CEO, Peter Greer, joins us today to invite the global community of Faith Driven Entrepreneurs and Investors to take action in a real, meaningful, and lasting way.
All opinions expressed on this podcast, including the team and guests, are solely their opinions. Host and guests may maintain positions in the companies and securities discussed. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as specific investment advice for any individual or organization.
Episode Transcript
Transcription is done by an AI software. While technology is an incredible tool to automate this process, there will be misspellings and typos that might accompany it. Please keep that in mind as you work through it.
Henry Kaestner: Welcome back to a special edition of the Faith Driven Investor podcast today we’ve got a special guest great friend of mine, Peter Career with us from Hope International and Peter. As so many of you will know, Rise, an incredible organization called Hope International, which focuses on Christ centered economic development, savings plans, savings groups, rather microfinance smear loans and assistance. And he does that and just pretty much all over the world and many, many countries that we’ll hear about. But one of those countries is particularly special to him and to the staff of Hope International, and that is the Ukraine. It’s in fact where Hope got started just about 25 years ago. He has 47 employees that are on the ground. He’s been coordinating a work with them to make sure they and their families are set, and he is in a great spot to give us a sense as to what’s going on in the ground. Hopefully not to put too much pressure on my great friend, but hopefully will give us a good flyover and help us to understand a bit more about what’s going on. There may maybe some of the history and some of the ethnicity and in some of what’s happened over the course of the last week in a way that you will be able to understand the conflict and understand what’s going on through the lives of those he knows on the ground in a way that would be different than to CNN or BBC. But hopefully you will leave our time together with a sense of what God is doing in the world, how he might call you into it. And at the very least, a way to pray differently about Ukraine in this crisis. Peter, welcome to the show.
Speaker 2: Thank you, Henry. So good to be with you.
Henry Kaestner: Awesome, have you? So we’re going to put this in the show notes, but I listen to a video presentation that you gave and event for the Denver Institute of Faith and Work last Tuesday or Wednesday, shortly after the conflict started. You know, it’s beautiful. It, it’s just awesome. And so I’m really grateful for you to be able to share some of that, some of the lessons of hope amidst a very tragic backdrop. But before we get into some of the things that you shared with that audience, give us, give us a sit rep. Tell us what’s going on today, please.
Peter Greer: Yeah, thanks, Henry. And I mean, the situation continues to rapidly change and we are continuing to pray for peace that this invasion would be over. But every day we’re in contact with the staff in Ukraine. As you said, Henry, 47, staff around the country, not all of them have been able to get to the West. Some are still very much in conflict zones, very close to the fighting. And I mean, you when you love someone, when they go through pain, you feel just a little bit of it to you. And I think that’s really just for the entire organization right now, all of the other countries feeling just a little bit of that, of that pain that our friends are experiencing right now. So in terms of what’s happening, there continues to be a mass exodus of individuals who are able to get out of Ukraine, estimated the right now 1.5 million people have evacuated. We know that males ages 18 to 60 are not able to exit, so there’s still a lot that are in country, but a lot of movement. I am thankful that the global business community is continuing to put pressure on Russia and Henry to think about the impact of business and this story that continues to unfold about a growing number of companies that are saying this is not OK and trying to figure out ways to make sure that the nation of Russia understands a little bit so really encouraged actually by what MasterCard, Visa, American Express are doing. Apple and a number of different companies that are saying we are going to suspend work in Russia as a way of trying to increase pressure on Vladimir Putin for this invasion to end. And in the midst of all of it, just an incredible show of solidarity and support among Ukrainians. The spirit of unity in Ukraine is so strong, and I have just the highest respect for our brothers and sisters right there that are facing incredible challenge and yet doing it with a spirit of unity that you have the world is seeing. So they’re continuing to pray for the peace talks, continuing to pray for peace and for all of us trying to figure out what does it look like to pray and to act in ways that very quickly, as soon as possible, this conflict will be over.
Henry Kaestner: Touch us a bit about the unity that you just mentioned. There are hope and there’s there’s a map. Hopefully we’ll have in the show notes to that shows where hope employees are and where there is conflict and their hope employees on the traditional Russian speaking side on the Far East and the Ukraine, and then also in the Ukrainian speaking side. Talk to us about this unity. One of the things that lots of us have been a little bit of a crash course on over the last two or three weeks is this kind of history of Ukraine, some different groups. And yet it’s not like all the Russian speakers are just like, can’t wait to be joined with the motherland, right? It seems quite the opposite.
Peter Greer: I think so. Within any country and. Any time we even have a conversation like this, it is real difficult to get to the overall, what is true in one region might be a little bit different for another region. And there certainly is nuance in the Donbass region. There certainly is history, right? But I think for me, the peace that has been a lesson for the world is what Zelensky has done and leading in a way of really coming back to that identity, coming back to who we are as a free nation, as Ukraine and watching the way that this truly has brought the nation together. And not just that, but I even think about my colleagues here at Hope International. The number of us you can’t see on video, but there’s a lot of blue and yellow that is being worn on that. And I think for you and me, Henry as followers of Jesus, a backdrop of pain and war and difficulty. This has always been a moment when the church shows up. The way the global church has showed up has been absolutely amazing and inspiring right now. So we have partners in Romania and Moldova and immediately for them to reach out to their colleagues in Ukraine and say if anyone needs to get out of the country, family members, we are here. We will meet you at the border. We will make sure you are in a safe spot and there is nothing we would not do for you. And that’s what we’re seeing from the Romanian church. That’s what we’re seeing from the Moldovan church. That’s what we’re seeing as individuals come in. And then even for organizations, Henry, just in the last several days, compassion international reaching out to their whole, you know, kind of support and saying Our friends hope international. They are in Ukraine. They’ve been in Ukraine for 25 years. They’re going to be there. And not just that and then us trying to point people to other organizations that are doing great relief work and celebrating the work of water mission. And there’s so many and I just love the way that this truly is bringing together the global church as it should. A moment of crisis should bring the church together and in a way that is so inspiring where it is not about organizational logos. This is about the global collective body saying, What can we do to make a difference for our brothers and sisters that are experiencing real suffering right now? So it has been a beautiful picture of unity at a national level for Ukraine. But I think it’s also been a beautiful picture of unity for the global church right now to
Henry Kaestner: tell us a bit about the size and scope of your ministry. I know you’ve got 47 employees. You were founded in the Ukraine. I actually want to get to their founding story a little bit because I know that we’ve had you on the podcast before, but I don’t know that we’ve gotten into that as much because now it’s so relevant. But who do those forty seven employees serve? And also tell us a bit about what we’re hearing on the ground from some of those hope clients.
Peter Greer: And the first thing that comes to mind, Henry, is just there is there is a fatigue that is very real. You hear it, you see it. You cannot live in a situation of that type of stress and concern for your kids, for your family members and it not take a toll. And now we are not on day one or two or three. This is long term stress and it is it is taking a toll on our friends. So I think that’s the reality of war, conflict, fear that impacts every part. You are not sleeping, unable to to eat. When you are focused on survival, you think about those families that are living in the subway. And if you’ve been in a Ukrainian subway mean built as bomb shelters, they are so incredibly deep. And that’s where families are living right now again. And it’s not short term now. It is going to be measured in weeks, not days of how long families are going to be living in that type of stressful situation. So clients, staff, the broader country is experiencing a level of trauma right now that is very real, very, very, very real. And when I think about the impact on the clients, we always know that it is the most vulnerable that are impacted the most severely. So, yeah, I mean, focusing on where do we get food focused on what is the safest place and and we can’t get there. The cities are shut off. As you said, 70 percent of our work is in the east in areas that now were under Russian control or still at the very forefront of the fighting. And if you saw the recent headlines of the nuclear power plant in Russia, that is the founding city of Hope, international and staff and lots of clients that are in that area. So I think that to me is just the reality of chronic fear and stress and the impact that that has on on an individual and at the same time, courage and compassion. We are seeing a response that is so unbelievably inspiring of people that are willing to sacrifice. Or someone else? Yeah, so there’s so much more that could be, said Henry, but that’s yeah, I think that’s
Henry Kaestner: give us a quick overview of the history, but then talk to us and bring that into the services and how a business in Ukraine will interact with you and the type of financial services that you provide. I think it’s important for us as an audience of investors to understand what does it look like to invest in businesses in a place like the Ukraine? And it may be too early for us to talk to you about, well, what is it look like to invest in businesses in Ukraine immediately after this? It’s probably too early. And yet you probably have a sense of what those businesses do and the services you’ve offered. And and presumably to the extent that there are some loans, there’s going to be some defaults. But just, yeah, just a bit history right through the services you offer. Yeah.
Peter Greer: Well, Henry, it’s not too early to talk about what is coming because we’ve been through this before in Ukraine. If you actually look at what happened after the fall of the Soviet Union, you look at what happened in the early 90s and you saw all of the challenge. And so Hope International came in with relief at the time, not Hope International, but the church that was involved in the founding of Hope International came in with relief because in a crisis, that’s what is needed and so provided food for those that were insecure, provided housing, started rebuilding churches and really seeing this opportunity to love. But relief is always best when it is targeted and it is time bound. And there was a moment that really was the turning point when Pastor Petrenko in Ukraine said to these individuals. And Jeff Wright, hopes founder. We sure appreciate all the aid that you’ve been providing, but isn’t there a way you can help us help ourselves? Isn’t there a way we can no longer become dependent on your charity and we can have the gift of work we can provide for our families? And that was the moment that Hope International was born. And really shifting from charity to then development. And so in a very similar way, that’s what we’re going to experience. There’s going to be a time of outpouring of charity that is good and needed and appropriate. And then I believe very quickly it’s going to be an opportunity to rebuild the enterprises, the small businesses, the micro entrepreneurs. It’s going to be a time to help them get back to work and rebuilding their nation. And so that was the founding story. That is what we continue to do, and that is what we are going to do. Been there for 25 years and we’re going to be there for the next 25 years, helping entrepreneurs rebuild. Initially, it was about the small scale markets, but then really got into agriculture. 60 percent of our work is investing in agriculture and greenhouses and helping with food production in Ukraine. And that is what we’re going to continue to do on that.
Henry Kaestner: Tell us how you do that. Do you compete against the banks in the Ukraine? I know enough about hope to know that you have programs and services on top of the lending, but give us an overview Aminu menu, if you will, of what you do when you’re working with one of these agricultural entrepreneurs, one of these farmers. And by the way, when you talk about insecurity, you’re talking about, people are just her hungry. And as an aside, this weekend, my family and I watched the movie The Pianist. This was an Oscar winning movie from maybe 30 years ago. Roman Polanski movie. Adrien Brody, I think won Best Actor for it. Incredible. And it did such a great job of talking about a period of time, which is interesting to watch right now. But you came away from that and just realized that very quickly somebody can become food insecure when all of a sudden the shops go and you just you’re hungry. And that becomes that was, you know, for two hours. Effectively, you watch Adrien Brody going around and trying to find food. You’re working with these farmers. What does it look like to be able to serve them as they look to to feed this country?
Peter Greer: Yeah. Well, unfortunately, the timing of this, as at a time of individuals should be planting right now. There should be a time where there’s a whole lot of work being done to get ready. So I do worry if if there is an inability to at this stage, be planting the seeds and plowing the ground. I do think there’s going to be a crisis in the months to come on that as well. So what does it look like? It looks like the agricultural inputs are being matched with the hardworking entrepreneurs, hardworking farmers and then helping them to feed their families and feed their nation. So on a practical level, it’s inputs. It’s access to capital so that individuals can get what they need to grow up a whole variety. But for us, a huge, huge emphasis has been in greenhouses that turns it from just one growing season a year to multiple growing seasons a year. So doing a lot with helping individuals have access to greenhouses as well.
Henry Kaestner: Tell us about that. Their lawns ever equity deals. How do you source those deals?
Peter Greer: Yeah. So we keep it real simple. We do all with loans, so we do not take equity in the different ventures, but started with. Real small loans, you know, 50, $100, 200, $500. And then as we’ve grown now, it’s in the thousands of dollars of investments. And so, yeah, it’s not by any means our largest country of operation, but it has been, yeah, long term commitment to walking with these entrepreneurs. And I guess Henry, again, my mind, I feel like I’m not able to really articulate this real well right now. It has been a tough, tough season because as we are with our clients and with our staff, there is this sense of a feeling like there’s not a whole lot we can do right now and we will be there when the rebuilding begins. We know that. And right now, safety and security of staff calling all of our clients and saying immediate grace periods. We know there’s going to be write offs. We know there’s going to be loan forgiveness. And I think that’s an opportunity to show the different of our model and methodology. If you had your store ransacked by an invading army, we are going to help you not through the normal mechanisms, but we’re going to help you get back in business through an outpouring of compassion and generosity. And again, just checking in with clients praying for them. And yeah, it’s real hard when you think about the work that we do in light of an invasion and just so desperately wanting this to be over so that that rebuilding time can come, but it’s not there yet. This is not a time to be planning fields yet. This is not a time yet to be restocking shelves for the micro-entrepreneurs. And so it just is this huge piece of just picking up the phone call and clients making sure staff know we’re with them and doing everything possible that they would just simply know we are here, that we see. We know we care. And in many ways, just getting ready for as soon as we can. There’s a whole lot of excitement and anticipation the day that there is peace. The rebuilding will begin. And yeah, that’s really what we are actively planning and preparing for.
Henry Kaestner: One of the key differences in your model versus those of other models that invest in developing markets is that you have this faith driven staff and a couple of things. It just occurred to me. Number one, I see the the fatigue in you knowing that this is something you’ve been wrestling with and looking at. And the second one is, I’m just so glad that you’re in the market in the theater, if you will, loving all people because it would seem to me that when you have forty seven people able to call business owners that they know that are all in all, 47 of these are driven by their Christian faith. There’s an opportunity to love on people that might be different. It’s going to be different. It’s got to be radically different than when times are great and hope is just another loan. You know, they could get one from a bank or someplace else. And yeah, the hope international pray for the employer will pray for them. But and maybe that resonates a bit. But this would seem to be this time that while the faith aspect of your model and of your workers on the ground really, really matters. Am I getting that right?
Peter Greer: Yeah, you’re absolutely getting right. We saw that in the founding years of Hope International. We saw that in the invasion in 2014, and we are seeing it right now and I couldn’t agree more. Henry, when your world is shaken, when what you have been accumulating, what you’ve been saving and investing, when that is taken away, the question is what do you have? And for those of us that are followers of Jesus, we believe you can take our businesses. We believe that there are challenges that we were experience. And in the midst of that, there is a hope that is unshakable because it is not dependent on our circumstance, but on the character of Christ. And if the tomb is empty, that has relevance for us today. And so, yeah, we have seen we have definitely seen in many cases working with clients for years and years and years. And then it’s in a moment of crisis that the door opens to conversations about what really matters. Is there a hope in the midst of everything falling apart? And we would say, yes, there is on that. So yeah, I anticipate I believe this. We’ve already experienced it and I believe we’re going to experience it in the months to come. If the church can mobilize and if the church can be on the forefront of caring, of responding and rebuilding. I believe there will be incredible opportunities for the gospel to advance in Ukraine right now.
Henry Kaestner: Speaking on Hope a bit, I was really impacted by your sharing about one of the prophets talking about hope amidst conflict and challenge. Tell us a bit about that as very, very relevant for what’s going on right now, but also has to do with a work that God has been doing on your heart for a while. And I think you’ve got a book coming out about this, but tell us about this hope that comes. Out of the profits that’s made such an impact.
Peter Greer: Henry, this has been an absolute gift for Christmas and I to work on really this question initially of how do some of our friends keep going for decade after decade when they have every right to be disappointed, disillusioned, cynical and give up? And they haven’t like what is it? And you know this we have these friends and they just they just have this, as Eugene Peterson says, this long obedience in the same direction and what is it that sustains that? And so thinking about Zimbabwe, why are they still serving your our friends in Haiti? What or thinking about all of our friends that have just had this long term faithful obedience? And we started doing a research project really of saying, what is it that grounds their long term service when there are incredible challenges? And the theme that they kept bringing up again and again was this idea of a grounded and rooted hope, and they kept bringing up again and again this Old Testament prophet that I could quote one verse from. I could quote Jeremiah to 911 for. I know the plans that I have for you declared the Lord’s plans to prosper. You give you hope in future not to harm you, and I could quote that, but I had no idea of the full scale and scope when those words were written down by Jeremiah. And you look at Jeremiah and it was in the midst of an invasion from an occupying force that destroyed his homeland. It was in the midst of him having incredible personal challenge, death threats and assault and slander and all of these challenge. And yet sometimes he’s known as the Weeping Prophet. I think that’s the wrong description. He’s the persevering prophet. He’s the one who had this long obedience in the same direction. And in Jeremiah, 17, it really points to this idea of what sustains his service and how did he keep going. And. And I think what he wrote down, what got the message that God gave through the prophet Jeremiah has so much relevance for all of us today. And it basically said, You know what? You try to do it on your own, your strength. So that is not going to be when the drought comes, you are going to break off and blow away only if you have a hope that is in the character of who God is. That is the only way that you can have green leaves and drought conditions. And as we listen to our global friends, that is what they kept, pointing the example of Jeremiah faithfulness that is independent of circumstance and a hope that is rooted in God’s character. And instead of like turning inward instead of focusing on all of our disillusionment or all of our pain or all of our disappointment, it simply is looking up and this wonderful promise that Jesus gave. So in this world, you will have trouble like we were told this is going to be hard. And any North American expectation that following Jesus is easy is an unbiblical expectation. This is supposed to be hard. This is supposed to be difficult. But what does Jesus say? Says, but take heart. I have overcome the world, and I think that’s what our friends in Ukraine know right now. This is ridiculously painful and hard to watch what is happening, but it is possible to experience the presence of Christ in the midst of it. And for our brothers and sisters in other contexts around the world that are also experiencing incredible challenge, they expected that this was going to be hard and they’re not trying to do it in their own strength, but they have found a way of connecting to the author of Life. The reason we have hope they have found a way that their faith is what grounds them, and they know that there is a different end to this story than the current circumstance.
Henry Kaestner: What an incredible, encouraging note to end on. We’re now linked to this in the show notes, but I just want to encourage listeners right now, as you wanted to know more about the work that I hope international does and then their take on what’s going on in the ground to include links on how to give and get involved with other ministries. One of my big takeaways from Peter is just the way that the global church is responding. And I love your open headed nature with the way that you’re calling attention to what Samaritan’s Purse is doing, A.W. and Water Mission and others. I really encourage you to check out the Hope International website and for us as listeners, as faith driven investors to be on our knees praying about how God might have us allocate our capital in light of what’s going on and understanding that there is an opportunity for us as Faith Driven Investor is to have this long obedience in the same direction and try to understand how God might have us deploy capital for us to think about doing that. In Ukraine, there are a couple of dozen or so other countries that hope works in and as well. But right now, I think that we are indeed looking at some troubles which are in Eastern Europe, so let’s hope that God. Lines as faithful as we think and pray about these things. Peter, I’m grateful for you. I’m grateful for our friendship. I’m grateful for your leadership. I’m so fired up about the new book that’s coming out so I can understand more about this pattern that you see. And I love that I love this concept of who can you look at that are really the heroes out there on the ground doing things in a way that after two or three months, we’re like, Gosh, this work is just too hard. We just we’ve got to quit. And you knowing that there are men and women motivated by their Christian faith out there that are sticking to it? What does that look like? They grit through a biblical worldview, and so thank you for that. And let me just pray for you and and hope Heavenly Father. We lift up Peter and his leadership, and I thank you for the fact that he’s had a faithful obedience in the same direction for 17 18 years now as a CEO of Hope International and the way that he’s been such a light for me and so many others, I thank you for the work of hope on the ground and a few dozen countries in Africa and Latin America and Asia. Just it’s amazing to see what they’ve done, what you’ve done through them. Dear Lord. Specifically, though, today we pray for those 47 families. We pray for the 47 families that you will bring them safety and security. And yet, Lord, that you’d also allow them to be able to continue to serve those clients. We pray for the clients, we pray for these businesses that we pray for the conversations that hope employees will have with these businesses and checking in and praying with them. Dear Lord, we pray for the safety of your church in the Ukraine, the men and women that are running these businesses that are trying to keep the businesses afloat, trying to love their families while trying to even just find food. Some of these clients might be living in subway stations right now, Lord, and I think that just my impatience when I have to sit in a subway station for ten minutes when I’m waiting for a train, as I did last week in New York, and think that they’re there for days or maybe even weeks or longer. Dear Lord, we just pray for the brokenness of this world. And yet we also understand that you have told us that there will be troubles in this world. Find his faithful and obedient and worthy of those troubles because you have indeed overcome the world. Help us know what that looks like. Dear Lord, forgive me for the fact that I too often do not have that perspective and I coast too often. Forgive me for that. Allow me to rise to the occasion. Allow these listeners to do the same in Jesus name. Amen. Amen, thank you, Henry. Bless you, brother. Really good to see you. Do I get to?
Episode 102 – The Gold Standard with David McAlvany
Subscribe to the Podcast:







David McAlvany is the CEO of the McAlvany Financial Companies – International Collectors Associates and McAlvany Wealth Management. He is a featured speaker on national television and radio programs including CNBC, Fox News, Fox Business News, and Bloomberg where he analyzes major events and their impact on the global economy and financial markets. David shares his story, discusses the importance of precious metals and reserves, and explains how Faith Driven Investors should think about these assets.
All opinions expressed on this podcast, including the team and guests, are solely their opinions. Host and guests may maintain positions in the companies and securities discussed. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as specific investment advice for any individual or organization.
Episode Transcript
Transcription is done by an AI software. While technology is an incredible tool to automate this process, there will be misspellings and typos that might accompany it. Please keep that in mind as you work through it.
Henry Kaestner: Welcome back to the Faith Driven Investor podcast. I’m here in our virtual studio and sweet with William Norvell William.
William Norvell: Greetings, greetings. Love the changes we’ve made at the virtual studio lately. It’s looking, looking fresh.
Henry Kaestner: It maybe, maybe it’s the same bookshelf, but you’re looking good. You look like you’re headed into a weekend with Alabama Crimson on. Is that right? Or is that
William Norvell: kind of what happens around weekend time for me? No, no. It’s a blend, but it’s Alabama Red Alabama.
Henry Kaestner: It’s not Stanford.
William Norvell: It’s not real. No, it’s crimson.
Henry Kaestner: Okay. All right. That’s good enough. So before we get into, we’ve got a really cool podcast guest today, we’re going to talk about a topic we’ve actually never talked about precious metals and what that looks like. And so I’m fired up for this for a whole bunch of different reasons, which will become manifest shortly. But before we do that, William, this is not the only podcast you have done, and we’ve been remiss in not mentioning a really good work that you had put out there in podcast land and to share real quickly with the FDE audience. What did you do? Why did you do it? Keep it to two minutes or less, as you have done with each of these podcasts, which is really cool. I mean, I can do a podcast episode this like two minutes long. So give us a description.
William Norvell: Podcast episodes are a lot shorter than my typical overview of my podcast, but yeah, now I appreciate that. Yeah, so Phil called the God to personally go through a journey to understand humility just as season of my life, where I just felt like I wanted to see what God really says about that. So I put together 50 really short devotionals and a 50 sounds like a lot, but they’re all less than five minutes. And I basically just read a passage of scripture and a couple of different translations and then have a couple of quick commentary. And then actually, I leave the last ninety to one hundred and twenty seconds just for reflection on what God might be saying to you through that podcast. So five seasons each goes through a different topic of humility and how we can play that out in our lives. And yeah, it was useful to me and thought maybe somebody else could learn something from it. You get a lot less of me and a lot more of the Bible, which is probably a great podcast.
Henry Kaestner: It was awesome, so I’ve been blessed by it. Thank you. I think that our listening audience can be blessed by two as a will by our guest today. OK, so I’m gonna set this up a little differently than we do. We are going to talk to David about his background, how he came to faith, how it informs what he does, and there’s a bunch of things about how he has a culture and his company, I think, are really worth exploring. But this podcast came out about a little differently than most do, and it came out of a source of almost like a mini debate. OK, so I’m I set the stage. All three of us, William David and I attend something called the Christian Economic Forum every summer, and it’s a great blessing. Chuck Bentley, who’s been on the program, is such a great leader, such a great guy. The conference is unbelievable. It’s just really some of the great thinkers from around the world, and it’s just awesome to go to. So a great friend of ours named Tom Darden led off and had encouraged Chuck to say, You know what? We had these great presentations, but let’s have a little debate. Let’s get a little contentious. Let’s go ahead and look at some issues that maybe there’s a we can have a healthy debate on. And so Chuck said, you know, in the next seventy five minutes, we can have this kind of debate atmosphere and let’s talk about some of the things maybe we disagree with a little bit. So he had a couple of speakers up and he or one of the speakers offered up this question how might you as a Christ follower hedge against inflation? Which is a great question. It’s a great question. Some of the panelists, some of the people then offered up some answers came from the perspective of cryptocurrency and then also precious metals. And so I felt compelled and challenged by Tom, who would say, let’s go ahead and have a healthy debate about things. I felt compelled to go up to the microphone and ask this question. And what I had offered up was in a world in which most Christ followers are not investing in their assets in a way that participates in underlying ministry. And by that, I mean by investing in real estate assets where there’s a corporate chaplain that might ministered to the people in the community or into private equity or venture capital, into faith driven entrepreneurs and expanding the work they do and creating redemptive products and services and things of that vein, things that you’d be relatively familiar with if you’ve been listening to podcasts. I said, if that’s the case, should we be really and we’re looking at precious metals and cryptocurrency, should we be instead asking about how do we take our portfolios and hedge against inflation? Should we instead be asking, how do we take our portfolios and hedge against Judgment Day? Now again, if you’ve been listening to podcasts, that’s not language. I use a lot, but I wanted to go ahead and play ball a little bit and be somewhat, you know, kind of throw in a kind of a debate form. And my commentary came across and it was meant to come across as offering up that there wasn’t a lot of spiritual immigration in precious metals or cryptocurrency with the underlying assets, and therefore a Christ follower should underweight them and shouldn’t focus on them as much. So at lunch, David, today’s guest came up to me and very, very, very thoughtfully and very gently helped me to understand. That there’s a lot more nuance there, there’s a lot more at work there, there’s a lot more redemptive purpose to precious metals than I had seen. And there’s a viewpoint and a perspective that as I heard it and as he walked me through it, I’m like, That’s really helpful and instructive. And I still, to be clear, still believe that crossfire is this incredible opportunity to participate with where the underlying assets proclaim God’s love and sovereignty and create redemptive price and service and things like this. And yet David’s perspective and his background and his expertize are super important for any Christ far to consider. And so, David, we’re going to do solidify. Typically, we start about the background of a gas and we’re going to get there. But let’s get right into it and talk about what did you come up with to me at lunch and say that made such an impact on me?
Speaker 3: Yeah, I think one of the things that is helpful in we can look at this from several different vantage points is to see gold as a reserve asset. And you know, is it something you’re speculating in like cryptocurrencies or are you thinking that it’s going to buy it at one acts and it’s going to be 10x tomorrow? It plays a very different role within a total portfolio. And one of the things that I wanted to visit with you about there in Colorado was this idea of gold being on a par with what we have incorporated into our other life in other areas. So for instance, you’re married, man, you understand that there’s a need for relational reserves and not a perfect husband. You may not be a perfect husband, perfect father. I certainly am not a perfect father. And in the continual investment sex that there is an excess reserve such that when there are relational drawdowns, you’re not taking the account negative. You know, that emotional reserve relational reserve biochemically were the same way you can throttle your body and biochemistry to a certain degree. But when you deplete your serotonin levels to a certain level, it’s game over. You’re talking about some clinical issues which have to then be treated. So whether it’s serotonin or cortisol, you bring things down to a certain level. You get to a critical point and you can’t recover. It’s the same with countries when they’re running foreign exchange reserves, you end up seeing currency crises, in particular countries where they run their reserves so low. Then all of a sudden external pressure emerges. They don’t have the resources to deal with it, and it’s game over. The Asian contagion that we saw late 90s was a perfect example of that, where Vietnam and Thailand came under intense pressure because their foreign currency reserves diminished to the point where they now had a currency crisis that followed. So reserves as an idea, I think, is where I would want to hang my hat with metals. And we do this to a certain degree. Already anybody who from a financial perspective, from a personal perspective, has an emergency fund has done that. Maybe you’ve got a month’s worth of expenses set aside or three months worth of expenses set aside, and that’s your kind of personal cushion. Why do we do that with our company as well? I think gold fills this role within a total portfolio as a reliable reserve. You look at the history of gold, it’s really just money. That’s what it’s been for five thousand years, and it happens to be something that has a stable value through time versus any paper currency, which frankly, the history of every paper currency to this point has been experimental. It’s genius inspired. And then all of a sudden it blows up. You know, we’ve been doing this for three thousand years. The first paper currency was the Chinese. So the question is, do you want your reserves in something that is intrinsically worth the ink and paper it’s printed on or representative of time and a very laborious process to actually get it out of the ground? So this is like energy in a packet. You have that reserve because there’s times in life where you need the reserves. We know that from an emotional, cyclical standpoint, that’s why we need emotional reserves when it comes to a business cycle. Sometimes things are booming, sometimes things are moving higher and it makes sense to have leveraged portfolio and there’s benefits to that. There’s other times where the market’s moving against you, and you may either be in a position to play the patience game because you didn’t have enough reserves and now you’re just sitting there waiting and saying, I hope I get back to break even someday. Or you have these reserves which allow you to lower total volatility and over the course of time, actually improve returns. So looking at gold as a portfolio allocation, it plays that role as a stable reserve and it’s intended to be put to use at some point. It’s not a debt asset. It shouldn’t be thought of as a good asset. And I think that’s the indictment that, for instance, Warren Buffett has certainly laid at the feet of gold. His father was a big proponent of gold when he worked in the Senate. But Warren had no interest in it, in his view, would be, Look, I want companies where you can see things being produced, culture changing, and I like the products everybody needs those products like. That’s an investment that I think can move forward through time. Gold said that asset would be his opinion. My view is that he appreciates the value of reserves, too. He’s currently sitting on a hundred and forty four billion dollars in cash, just as Apple sitting on $240 billion in cash and liquid assets. The question when you’re looking at cash in liquid assets ends up being denomination, denomination, denomination. We take this for granted in the US because the dollar is relatively stable. Maybe it’s not so much this year, but that’s no big deal, really. If you go to Brazil or in recent years, Argentina, where the annual inflation rate is twenty five to thirty five percent, a few years ago, it was as high as 45 percent in one year. You’re basically cutting the value of your savings in half if you leave them in something that would be considered a cash reserve. So the denomination question becomes an issue, and I’m not pretending to be a currency expert where, okay, I don’t want to be in dollars. Should I be in Swiss franc? Should I be in yen? Should I be in euros? What I’m saying is that for 5000 years, a reliable store of value savings and actually what was considered money up until 1971 on a global basis was gold. So it is a reliable reserve. The need for reserves, I think that’s where it kind of speaks for itself. We know business cyclicality. Sometimes you need it and you’re glad when you have it. That’s one of the things that I think we learned from 2008 and 2009. The global financial crisis did not start out as a, you know, liquidation of companies because they were under duress. It started out when Lehman and Bear Stearns left and they didn’t have enough in capital. It was a liquidity crisis before it became a solvency crisis and arguably the weeks leading up to the solvency crisis, they would have said, We have ample liquidity. We’re fine. Liquidity disappeared. And that’s when things began to snowball in 2008 and 2009. So reliable reserves is an issue, an asset that is outside of the financial system. So essentially you’re removing it from counterparty risk. These are the aspects that make gold a solid reserve. I mean, I think that’s a part of what we talked about.
Henry Kaestner: It is. And so I’ll tell you how I’m applying it. I don’t want to put words in your mouth, but I’ll tell you how I’m applying it. You can tell me if I’m thinking about the right way, and that is that there are going to be different faith driven investments I’m going to get excited about in a year’s time, 18 months time, twenty four months time and what I need to wrestle with. And maybe this be interesting to actually talk about just a little bit and get your take on. But generally, I don’t know that I want to be 100 percent invested right now in illiquid private equity and all its investments. I want to be able to have some money that’s available if I see a compelling opportunity to give, for instance, because I think that this is the broader stewardship. If there’s, you know, a calamity or some place that is clearly that God might have my capital deployed in a way that advances kingdom philanthropically, I need to have some liquidity or, as you would say, reserve if there is a Great Kingdom investment opportunity, same type of thing, say, 18 months or 24 months. And I think that it maybe we’ll get this in the second again about, well, what is that right ratio? You know, Tom Darden, who we had talked about before, who had introduced this kind of concept of a healthy debate is famous for being completely deployed. He’s always completely deployed now. He has a diverse portfolio where he has one hundred plus private investments, and in any given year, two or three of them are coming due and having a liquidity event. So he tends to have some level of liquidity just by virtue of the fact that it’s very diverse. And yet he would probably also say that he never really manages for liquidity because he’d rather have those assets always deployed, always working towards those things that Warren Buffet would say. I don’t know that I’d go to that extreme. And I, for instance, would like to see some percentage of. Available to be able to honor a guy’s car and see some of the opportunities, but am I getting it that the right way and that that is something that if OK, Henry, if that’s the case and you want to take 10, 15, 20 percent of your portfolio and have it in reserve to be able to answer God’s call and see opportunities? What I’m suggesting to you is that precious metals is absolutely a place that you might keep that and maybe you keep it in cash. Maybe you don’t, but you should be thinking about precious metals in that regard. Am I getting it right?
David McAlvany: Yeah, I think you are. Because again, what you’re doing is you’re setting the mindset of this should be put to use. And I think this is where it when you look at the parable of the talents, you can see someone who had no intention of putting something to use. It was strictly buried versus someone who had every intention of having a resource and putting it to use. And my suggestion is that the multiplication factor this is perhaps a I’m not a theologian, so feel free to critique this, but the multiplication factor that you see in the parable of talents, it can happen a couple of different ways. You buy an asset at one X and it goes to 10x because it was a great growth prospect, opportunity, et cetera, et cetera. Or you buy an asset at One X. That’s trading at a fraction of one X. In other words, you’re trained to understand the value and what real value looks like. So if that’s a 100 acre farm or 100 shares of General Electric or a private equity venture where you say this is really priced attractively, I should be doing something about this where value gets factored in in a major way. Well, the point is putting it to work opportunistically, which is, I think where you’re hitting the nail on the head, yes, you want to be able to have enough liquidity that you can deploy opportunistically. We have a really interesting situation now because ordinarily a business cycle ebbs and flows. If you look back, say, two or three hundred years even stretching back into the British mercantile history, you had about a three to five year business cycle and they were many booms and busts. Nothing really catastrophic. But, you know, 60 and 94 was the creation of the central bank, the Bank of England. We had our central bank kind of catch its legs, the second iteration in 1913. This was the second central bank of the United States with the first one down. But what has happened is we’ve basically said we think we can manage the business cycle more effectively. There will be no more declines. There’s no reason for us to ever have a recession. And so there’s a certain presumption that now exists within the central bank community. That is, if we push this button, pull that lever, we’ll never see a recession. But what it’s done is it’s extended periods of growth, but it’s also made the down strokes much more catastrophic. When they lose control, they really lose control. And so I think we’re in a different environment where the opportunities could arguably be better. Having liquidity available your question and maybe I’m running ahead, so feel free to rein this in. But your question of kind of proportionately what that would look like. I know much of the discussion you have is around Faith Driven Investor and it takes you to the private markets. If I looked at the backtesting in the public markets, which is where I can get pretty decent data going back a couple hundred years, you would look at a ratio of about seventy five twenty five seventy five percent allocated to assets that are growth oriented. So in my case, that would be capital markets, the equity markets that the S&P 500 did, that would have it. Seventy five twenty five is an interesting mix because three quarters of your allocation is oriented to growth, but with 25 percent allocated to gold. Any major down stroke if you’re doing an annual rebalance once a year annual rebalance Any down stroke in the market means you’re putting that liquidity to work at much lower numbers, and your return to full value isn’t that long. Patience game of equities are down 30 percent or 60 percent, or, you know, we had tech stocks in 2000 2001, down 80 90 percent, right? It’s not the Long March back to break. Even you were able to redeploy on a lot more at a lower number, and your recovery cycle is that much shorter. So if you’re looking at total returns, that’s 75 twenty five mix. Even though you’re taking 25 percent horsepower out of the growth equation, over a 50 100 200 year period ends up being a superior rate of return, a more aggressive growth portfolio because you’re avoiding the major down strokes. Or I should say the down strokes are less impactful. That makes sense.
William Norvell: Now that does. That’s really one of the things you just mentioned was a long time horizon. I want to dig into that for a little bit from a Faith Driven Investor perspective. You mentioned 10, 15, 20 years. How do you think about that? You know, you’ve been investing a majority of your career in life. How do you think about that from a faith perspective? Do you have, you know, but. It’s a twenty five year horizon and buckets of one year horizon, I mean, you know, we’ve got a lot of listeners that are brand new to this and figuring out what this could look like in their life. Do you have a year philanthropic budgets and 20 year philanthropy? I know that’s kind of a broad question, but I’m just curious your overall perspective on portfolio management from a faith driven perspective.
David McAlvany: Yeah, I mean, I think your reference to buckets is helpful because there is no single asset class that is deserving of 100 percent of your time, attention and resources. I look at precious metals is one of many investments, and there are specific ways to utilize precious metals effectively. Right. So that’s one bucket and there’s different in that market. There are arbitrage opportunities and an ability to compound ounces in a very compelling way. So even if you said, well, it’s just sitting there collecting dust. No, no, no. I would tell you that after 50 years of being in the business as a family, they’re very productive ways to turn a thousand ounces of silver into 2000 ounces of silver without adding money to that portfolio or gold or what have you. So management style within a bucket is also important. First bucket precious metals. Second bucket cash. The third bucket real estate. The fourth bucket stocks and bonds in the fifth bucket would be sort of private assets that could be private equity and alternatives. It could be a business that you own and control. So not everybody has the fifth bucket. If you’re talking about an entrepreneurial venture, but you might have that fifth bucket if it was in the adult category, where again, it doesn’t fit the traditional daily traded stocks and bonds, cash, precious metals or real estate. But there’s ways that as a steward, you can engage in harness income and growth within each of those buckets. And that’s where, you know, appreciating what value looks like, deepening your understanding of the dynamics that drive each one of those asset classes. Some people choose to have one focus on one asset class. I think the best way to approach stewardship and wealth management across multiple generations is to say appreciate the value that each of these buckets can provide. Precious metals will never provide the same kind of income component that say a commercial real estate portfolio would have right, and there’s risks and potential pitfalls within commercial real estate that you are not going to have within multifamily or single family. I mean, to all that complexity is a part of our ongoing effort to understand and make wise decisions in each of those areas. Diversification I take is a given, with each of those buckets being an opportunity to learn and to grow and to come alongside experts who can shorten the time frame, step in the learning curve and help us get farther along in terms of the progress of stewardship.
Henry Kaestner: OK, I want to go backwards here a little bit. This is kind of the Upside Down podcast interview because at this point in time, some people may be asking Who is this guy? And this guy’s an author and is a podcast as he owned
William Norvell: a gold ETF. Does he want to invest in it?
Henry Kaestner: Yeah, that’s right. Yeah. Where is this going? So David, I want to start from the beginning. We’re going to come back up. There are the questions that we want to ask about this, but why don’t you tell the audience about who you are? Let’s go through an autobiographical sketch. And if you don’t mention the whole part about the triathlons and the podcast, then I’m going to ask you about them.
David McAlvany: Well, I mean, for some people, the autobiographical sketch can be put into a paragraph. It took me about fifty six pages. I wrote a book, If
Henry Kaestner: you don’t have that much time.
David McAlvany: I know, I know. The Intentional Legacy was a book that I wrote in 2017, and it’s a very personal look at what goes into managing resources where we’ve basically redefined a balance sheet to save their spiritual aspects of the resources that we’re managing. There’s emotional aspects, and that’s a resource we have to manage. There’s interpersonal and relational capital that needs to be managed well because the reality is, you know, and I know we’ve all met people who have vast resources of money, and yet there’s pockets of poverty in their life and you can say, well, they didn’t do a really good job managing a relationship with a brother or a father or a grandfather or an uncle. And you can see sort of the unwind of that aspect of their life. So to me, managing resources is really important. I could only approach the topic of legacy from a very personal perspective. And so the intentional legacy starts with sort of our family dysfunction and the things that we’ve learned about our best attempt to do a better job at managing resources. And so I mean, we could start anywhere running away from home at age 14, living away from home for a year at a boys home, really finding faith at age 16 and allowing the pendulum to swing from agnosticism to really concerted effort to make up for lost time. Yeah, I don’t know many 15 16 year olds who are dead set on reading everything that Dietrich Bonhoeffer has ever written and diving into spiritual formation. And sort of. The classics of Christian Faith. But that was me at age 16, looking back with some regret at an early age, saying, What have I done? What am I doing? What is meaningful to me, looking forward is very different than what I thought was meaningful. Just a few years ago. And so the recapture took me to studying philosophy theology at Baylor. And, you know, just to sort of fast forward
Henry Kaestner: how long have before. If I do want to fast forward, I want to get there. But I just have to reflect and just acknowledge the fact that that is amazing. And maybe it’s just because I’m the father of three teenage boys, none of whom I’d like to think. Maybe they know who Dietrich Bonhoeffer is. But reading everything he’s written and making me think that and I hadn’t. That’s amazing. That’s incredible. I mean, that’s really so you’re looking back with some regret on lost time when you were 16 years old.
David McAlvany: Yeah. And you know, the advice my dad gave me was study finance. Study business is very practical. You need to know something about marketing. And he just says, I mean, he was engaging with the world and giving me advice that absolutely made sense in terms of professional operational place in the world. But I was still trying to unpack Who am I and what is this all about anyways? So for me, bipolar was this perfect place to ask big questions and to be mentored by men and women who had razor sharp minds and soft and tender hearts. And Henry and I experienced it by all has informed the way I pray for my kids every night, which is that they would have strong minds and soft and tender hearts. And that’s because that’s what I saw with these people who had a passion for the gospel and seeing God’s kingdom come. But these were no slouches when it came to their professional credentials. Their ability to engage the content matter that they were responsible for winsome, severe even. I mean, they took it really seriously, and I loved it.
Henry Kaestner: What a great commercial for a great university. Gary Lindblad runs a program there for business, and he’s just an amazing guy. He is incredibly winsome. I don’t know if you know you must know Gary. Gary just is led in 80s rock band and has music videos out there. His yet they’re fun part about him, but he is a deep thinker, passionate about his craft and loves the Lord and just makes me want to spend more time with him. So I’m a big baseball fan too.
David McAlvany: Yeah. You know, you graduate with a degree in philosophy and you don’t have sort of a stack of offers. Actually, my wife graduated with a degree in philosophy, and she did have a stack of offers, including from Goldman Sachs. Maybe it’s where you go to school as well. Boston College is slightly different in terms of pedigree than Baylor,
Henry Kaestner: but Bill is yet in there,
David McAlvany: so formation was absolutely critical. That was the big benefit to me of being at that place. You know, fast forward to joining our family business in 2003. I spent some time working at Morgan Stanley. And, you know, between a variety of start ups, including Restaurant Lunch with my brother in law like this is all sort of post-college leading into twenty five newlywed learning. All I could about Wall Street and the things that my dad originally said, you know, you should take an interest in this. I think you’ll find it very intriguing how finance ends up being this hub where everything from international relations and public policy and economics and it all comes together in the market mechanisms that are pricing assets constantly and taking into account the new information that you’re getting from all of these various sources. I think you’re going to find it interesting, and it took me years to come back around and say, You know, my dad’s pretty smart. He’s right. It’s really interesting. It’s fascinating. So that’s the world that I’m engaged in today. We have an asset management company that focuses on hard assets like infrastructure and specialty real estate and precious metals and global natural resources. We have the precious metals brokerage company, which my parents started 50 years ago, and I manage both of those businesses. What drives me every week? Henry is doing what we’re doing right now. I’ve done a podcast for the last 15 years every week, and the Mac Mini weekly commentary is a place for me to continue to allow my curiosity to just run free to ask questions that I don’t have an answer for, and to explore and to discover all the things that I wish I had known. 15 and 14 and 12 and 10 and even last year. So I think one of the things that I love about finance in the markets is it’s constantly humbling.
Henry Kaestner: Yeah. So tell me. So I just want to go back in one thing and look at if I think about the opposite of precious metals brokering precious metals investing. I think about investing in in a restaurant. And I’m wondering if you have because I do, it’s a leading question. I’m curious if yours is the same. I wonder if you have a favorite movie about investing in restaurants or the restaurant business.
David McAlvany: Favorite movie about investing in restaurants with the restaurant business.
William Norvell: The esoteric question part of this is yes, that’s right.
Henry Kaestner: That may or may not. Take it to the final version.
David McAlvany: Yeah. I got a love, there’s so many movies that I love about food.
Henry Kaestner: Yeah, you have babette’s feast and oh, it’s amazing delegates
David McAlvany: mean and Babette’s Feast is is is phenomenal. I think one of the things that I like about that, it’s feast as you get to see someone who loves taking care of people and looks at their skill set and says, This is how I care. This is how I love. So to me, one of the things that’s so gospel centric about that movie is that she’s doing the essential translation, the essential translation of what am I supposed to do with my life? Well, OK, God’s given us a certain amount of DNA hard coding. I’m inclined to be a certain person, just like William, just like Henry is, and we get to express and bring glory to God through the things that he has hardcoded into us. And so you see the chef create something of beauty, and it’s a celebration of these are people who never spoke. You know, you’ve got this whole town that they don’t get along this, but she’s bringing peace and she’s an emissary of love and servant hood, using her skill as the best way to facilitate change in this community. It’s beautiful, beautiful. You could take that and say, Yeah, but my skill sets differ and I could never fix that face. No, but you can set a different table in a different context and you should Amen.
Henry Kaestner: OK, so that’s great one. That’s not what I was looking for, but that is it is a great one, and I may submit that that’s actually better than the one I was thinking about, which is big night featuring Stanley Tucci in the restaurant business. This rivalry between these two Italian restaurants and one wants is passionate about their craft and doesn’t want to cut corners, and the other one is all about glitz and just about marketing and just the rivalry between the two. I think is fascinating. OK, but what kind of restaurant did you have?
David McAlvany: It was a fondue restaurant.
Henry Kaestner: Oh man, I love until we just did a Faith Driven Investor event in Zurich last week and coming off the heels of five Faith Driven Entrepreneur meetings in Romania, which were amazing. Unbelievable. The night before the Faith Driven Investor event in Zurich, our host Thomas Winkler, took us out to a local fondue place, and I may have had, without exaggeration, three and a half pounds of fondue. It was awesome. I think there must be some margin in that, though, because they charge us a lot of money for what I thought was just Emmental, our cheese and a little bit of white wine. But maybe the margins aren’t as big as I thought they were.
David McAlvany: No, the margins are OK. What we loved was it was an expression of our family. This is something that we’ve been doing since I was. I mean, for every year, I can remember we do a fondue feast every year and, you know, to have people come and be a part of that at our dinner table and to be able to open a bottle of wine and sit there and relax and talk. And I mean, it’s a very entertaining meal because there’s a lot going on. We do the cheese fondue. We also do the meat reckless and we’ve got chocolate fondue. So it’s a multi-course thing that takes three or four hours. So it’s the conversation, it’s the activity, it’s the matching with sauces. And I mean, we just have a great time with it. But it’s an anchor to relationship. And for us, having a restaurant that facilitated that for other people was amazing. I managed the front of the house, he managed the kitchen and to sort of literally set the table and have people just enjoy themselves for three or four hours. This is common in Europe, but we’re in and out in 30 45 minutes max. That’s the American style. And to try to sort of refashion how to celebrate one sitting a night max two sittings a night where you’ve got the place just to sit and relax.
Henry Kaestner: I was talking to somebody yesterday who was talking about his time in Israel and how he learned about Shabbat. He was an investor in Taiwan from the HTC family. Super Guy really serious about his Christian faith guys degree at Fuller and as a technology investor in crypto and blockchain. But he talked about the formative experience in his faith and that he’s trying to replicate in his family of Shabbat because he lived in Israel for a while doing some technology investing and just the three hour intentionality of what Shabbat means for Orthodox families and the beauty that happens around the dinner table and talking about faith. And, you know, no technology, no phones and just a focus on faith and food. And that’s a it’s a beautiful thing. I did not think we’d be talking about this on today’s podcast.
William Norvell: So this is not in the show notes no, but movie recommendations coming soon from Faith Driven Investor babette’s feast. Big night. Now we got some good ones. Indeed. Well, actually, that’s a perfect tradition. One of things we did want to talk about. We’d be remiss not to David. So you’ve been talking a lot about gold. You know, we’re all quick hit people. You know, we’re all trying to make money, right? So some of our listeners are, too. We’d love to two part question one. What’s the future of gold prices right now? How do you think about that? And to how do you think about what people are calling digital gold the big? Coin and crypto revolution, but bitcoin specifically and we’ve had a great guest, Jimmy Song, who came on, you know, just to talk about bitcoin specifically because I feel like that’s one of the few cryptos that is be talking about a store of reserve, right? That’s one of the few that people are comparing in that way. Do you buy that? Do you not and not like, are you putting a buy recommendation on it? But just how do you think about the new concept of a digital bank? Well, the story value is that real? Not real? Yeah.
David McAlvany: So let’s start with the second part and then go back to the first. With cryptocurrencies, you’ve got something that is incredibly innovative. Blockchain technology stands to be integrated into a lot of different economic spheres, and it’s working its way in as we speak. You know, there’s years of development and decades for it to continue to mature and have an impact. We’ve seen it in Eastern Europe, where governments have decided that they don’t want their records changed. They don’t want history to be fluid if something has happened. They want those documents to be immutable. So the blockchain has allowed for Eastern European countries to lock in time. What has happened and I like that there’ll be other iterations of that. You was smart contracts and a whole host of other things. What I would say is that it’s primarily served as a vehicle speculation to this point. And as it matures, it may have other features to it, but it still is functioning largely as a speculation price goes up, the price goes down. When the price goes down, enthusiasm wanes when the price goes up. Everyone’s a believer. So there is that dynamic afoot with the cryptocurrencies not to take away from their long term trajectory, but in the short run, they’re primarily a vehicle for speculation. And in that sense, there’s at least one big contrast with gold. Looking at the gold market and looking how gold is priced and where, I think it’s going to be priced in future years, I think this ties to where we’re at in a number of cycles. We’ve had a 12 year growth cycle in equities. That’s been helpful. But now you look at things like price to sales, price to earnings. We’re now in the nosebleed section. So from a valuation perspective, I think gold is relatively cheap compared to bonds and stocks and is going to have significant growth relative to those two asset classes over the next two to three years. Again, I mean, look at something even like the buffet ratio. We talked about Warren Buffett earlier. Buffett ratio takes all stock market capitalization and compares it to GDP. We’re now at the highest level we’ve seen in the history of the US markets, where the engine of growth that is GDP is now a fraction of the size of this speculative representation of the growth. So in past market cycles, it’s peaked at about 180 or 210 percent of GDP. That is stock market capitalization of GDP. We’re currently at 322 percent, a stock market capitalization to GDP. This is the most stretched in terms of valuations we’ve ever seen. The stock market, so arguably the energy change out of equities will promote safe haven buying for gold, just as it will safe haven buying for treasuries and other safe haven assets. But I think that is a big play for growth dynamics in the gold market within, say, a 12 to 24 month period of time. Add to that the layer of fiscal and monetary policy largesse, which would have people saying Is there ultimately consequences to running our debt levels to twenty eight trillion dollars? Thirty five trillion dollars, fifty trillion dollars? I mean, just pick a number because under modern monetary theory, the number can be any number and we’re not supposed to be afraid of it. So that number is likely to grow as it was growing under the Trump administration. It’s growing under the Biden administration. It doesn’t matter who takes over in two years or four years. The trend is radical fiscal policy and monetary policy largesse. There’s discussions among the whole cohort at the Fed. They’ll trim things back, be less aggressive. I think what they will find is when they actually do that, the consequences into the marketplace will be so grave that they have to come right back with more quantitative easing measures and again, more monetary policy push, which has significant currency market implications. Right. So currency market implications, a devaluation of the dollar as a result of fiscal policy largesse and monetary policy largesse also has on the other side of the equation, in implication for gold at much higher prices. Price for inflation If we wanted to bring history into this price for inflation, gold should be right around twenty $800 an ounce. That is its inflation adjusted price. When a market moves to extremes, you can see that not on a sustainable basis, but you can see something go to say to two and a half times its inflation adjusted price. If I had to pick a cap, I’m not going to give you a timeframe for this, but I think the cap on gold is probably five thousand an ounce. That’s twice its inflation adjusted price. And at that point, you’ve been through a speculative push, not sustainable. I think we ultimately come back down and settle into a new generational sort of flat line or plateau between 2500 and 3000 at or above whatever the inflation adjusted price is after this next major move. So that’s a little context. I do think gold has some upside. Silver is kind of a different animal. It is considered a monetary metal in its past, but it’s taken on so much of an industrial component in its uses and everything from cell phones and flat screen televisions to nanoparticles and biotechnology. That it kind of has a foot in both worlds is a monetary metal and is something that has very practical uses and is being used up. If gold has decent upside from a growth perspective. I think silver has phenomenal upside, but it’s a different animal too, because it has that characteristic where if you got into a slowing of the economy, one of the major sources of demand can diminish, and so it doesn’t necessarily have to follow in lockstep with gold. I’ve probably spoken
William Norvell: behind. That’s great. That’s great. And you know, and for reference, if you’re listening and don’t know the price of gold, gold’s about 7500 right now, give or take. So when you’re talking about that, and like I said, this is not a stock picking podcast, but I’m curious because it is a little esoteric. I don’t think a lot of people own goal, but I mean, if you watch any CNBC report, you hear this passively said, Hey, five percent of your money in gold, you hear Jim Cramer, you hear other people say that there are so many financial instruments in the world. I am curious, is there a in your particular opinion for a retail investor who says, who’s listening? Yeah. You know, two or three percent in gold, I’m convinced to look into that. Is there a better or worse way to purchase the asset?
David McAlvany: Well, there’s definitely better and worse ways to provide.
William Norvell: I figured.
David McAlvany: Yeah. I mean, you know, right now there is such supply constraints in the physical market that certain products you have to pay 30 or 40 percent over the spot price. And I’m thinking of like an American Silver Eagle, it’s a bullion coin. And yet, because there’s not much supply and demand is fairly robust, I’m not going to pay 30 percent over. I wouldn’t touch that with a ten foot pole. Right. So there’s there are ways that you can definitely go the wrong direction. One of the things that we did a few years ago and this is, I mean, full disclosure, this is a point of personal self-interest. A few years ago, we launched a program with the Royal Canadian Mint called Vaulted and Vault. It allows you to buy a fraction of a kilo bar or an entire kilo bar. Kilo bars about 32 ounces of gold. And the platform is digital. You can go online about two weeks. You’ll be able to go to the App Store and download the vaulted app, and you can treat this like a savings account, but it’s denominated in gold. The benefits are you’re getting the economy of scale off of the kilo bar, right? So you’re not paying high premiums. The commission structure is crushed. We’ve taken out the middleman. We’re buying gold directly from the Royal Canadian Mint. So the economics are brilliant, but you have an allocated gold position, which you can take delivery of if you want. On the other hand, if you don’t want to bother with it, then it’s there in digital form and you can buy it and sell it and get liquid in two days. So better liquidity than your T plus three transactional settlement on a security like a stock or a bond. Better liquidity than that. But in a denomination going back to what we talked about earlier, a denomination that you may want to have a part of your cash in, so easy to buy, easy to sell, inexpensive, reliable counterparty Royal Canadian mounted to crown property in Ottawa. And that’s an easy way vault at that time. That’s an easy way to own the asset. Some people would say, No, I’d rather have it in my physical delivery, or can I hold it in an IRA? All of those are options with different cost structures, different limitations. But you wanted something simple. That’s the vault
William Norvell: itself. Yeah, no, that’s great. And anything can go on the web now. And so I assume the app’s going to function like Coinbase or something where you’ve got things going on and you can buy a $500 worth of gold and you have a wallet in the portfolio.
David McAlvany: Yeah. And I mean, what inspired this was having kids who like that elected on gold too. And like, all right. Well, it’s seventeen hundred bucks. Just wait a while, you know, you can save for a while and they always bought silver because it was cheaper. In this case, you can spend $5 if you want to spend five dollars on gold. Essentially, what it has done is it’s democratized gold ownership, and it’s no longer sort of you have to have lots of wealth to own it. Know if you wanted to nominate a part of your savings and something that is helpful on the inflation front serves there as a reserve asset is incredibly liquid. I mean, think about this the whole process of owning gold, having something shipped to you and then you say, Well, I want to sell it. It’s two weeks, three weeks. By the time you ship it back, lock in a price. Have something wired back to you. We’ve basically taken all of the complications of owning metals and eliminated them.
Henry Kaestner: How about the you probably get this a lot and I know so little about the market, as evidenced by, you know, my questions on this podcast and before. But what about the exchange traded funds like GLD or other things where it pros and cons of perfectly adequate?
David McAlvany: I mean, you know, some would say, well, there’s not gold there. That’s not true. I mean, if you want, you can print the bar list and know how many bars are in something like gold or silver. It’s fine. I do think that there may be issues down the line. This is a future tense concern, not a present tense concern. By the way, we own those ETFs in our asset management company as a part of our cash reserve. So I don’t object to them, but I do think that in the future there may be issues with them. They’re buying gold off of an exchange and the initial purchases are made in the form of futures contracts. Those futures contracts then sell within a certain amount of time, and the gold is moved into the GLD custodian accounts. There are circumstances in which there’s no more gold on the exchange to purchase, or there’s 10 people who’ve bought the same ounce of gold sitting on the exchange. And now the question is who gets the one ounce? And so it remains to be seen how GLD insult being. The exchange traded products will operate under difficult market conditions under normal market conditions. They’re just fine on a normal market conditions. They’re just fine, which is why I’m not worried about having them as a part of the position. But I do think that if you’re looking at gold from the standpoint of sort of an enduring asset or a ballast asset within a larger portfolio, maybe you want to take physical delivery of it. Maybe, yeah, I mean, there’s a variety of boxes that you personally may want to check, and in light of those boxes, then you’re going to look at a particular product that fits your needs. And that’s, you know, that’s worthy of conversation. Not not today, but I mean, it’s worthy of thinking through,
William Norvell: gosh, amazing, amazing tour of the world here. I feel like we covered a lot and we just got started. So like, I have 10 other questions on intentional legacy, and we’ll obviously link to the book and then people can read more about that. We’ll obviously link to your podcast if they want more commentary from you on things that you’re seeing in the world. But unfortunately, we have to wrap this episode, and the favorite way we love to do that is to see how God’s word transcends our guest and our listeners. And so we’d love to invite you to share a scripture or story from the Bible that may be coming alive to you right now could be something you read this morning could be something in the season you’ve been meditating on, but we’re just always amazed how God’s word is alive and well and transcending his people daily until it invites you to do that.
David McAlvany: There’s a number of mornings where we’ll get together as a family and I’ll share something from scripture. And honestly, I just open and start reading and then just allow the spirit to kind of guide the conversation in the early chapters of acts. This was from last Friday in the early chapters of acts. You have something that I think is it’s just beautiful. You’ve got a doctor. It’s assumed that Luke wrote both Luke and acts, and it’s a doctor’s observation. Two disciples walk into the temple. I think this is Chapter five, and there’s the man who’s been paralyzed for 40 years and he asks for some money and he’s like silver and gold. I don’t have. But in the name of Jesus Christ, get up and walk. And what I wanted to convey to my. Kids, was that God’s appreciation of time and flexibility in terms of engagement with time is on display here as much as it was at the wedding of Keener as much as it was in the first chapter of Genesis. You know what we understand about Genesis? Clearly, some people think that that’s seven days and other people think that it’s a lot longer period of time. All I know is that God, in his infinite power, has the ability to work with time in ways that are amazing. Wine is an amazing thing. The fermentation process, what goes from grape juice to something that has an expression of terroir and has beautiful nuance. He resolves in a second at the wedding of Cana and Luke. Only Luke, a doctor, would appreciate that this guy who is healed in front of the temple gets up and not only walks but is leaping. Have you guys ever broken an arm or had, you know, something where you weren’t able to use your muscles for a long period of time? This is a guy who for 40 years has never used his legs. He doesn’t know how to walk. He is leaping. He has musculature, which in a second is me. To me, it’s so beautiful because in our lives, we’re concerned about these events or this having to happen or our time friends, or maybe even think about retirement marking things out according to our sense of time. And we forget that God in his sovereignty and in his great love and compassion. Can turn water into wine and compress time in a beautiful way. For just joy and celebration or God, and his compassion can take this person who’s never walked before and say, not only will you walk, but you will leap, you will jump. And you’ll do it with muscles you never had before. And so I just I love the idea that time, you know, legacy is something that’s important to me, and I’m making decisions that maybe have an impact, hopefully have an impact 20 years from now, 100 hundred years from now, 200 years from now. And we have our concept of time. But we do need to keep in mind that kingdom time can be very compressed and being sensitive to the decisions that we make and how they fit into God’s time and God’s plan. You know, I think that’s what I would leave with you is that passage and acts just as a wonder in terms of our concept of what are we working with here?
Henry Kaestner: Amen What is terroir
David McAlvany: here was the unique expression that a particular patch of soil gives the grapes that grow in it. So if you’re on the valley floor in Napa, this is an old river valley. It’s rich soil, and it gives a unique characteristic which is just flat rich. If you go to Howell Mountain or go into the hills 700 to 1000 feet higher, those vines struggle to even survive. They send down their roots hundreds of feet just to get a little bit of water, and the grapes express the ground that it’s grown in. So if you’ve struggled, the grapes express it. If you haven’t had to struggle and it came easy. The fruit expresses it. Terroir is the unique expression of that soil in that particular grape.
Henry Kaestner: I would now use our three times to the rest of the day
William Norvell: and word of the day. Word of the day is there to say, everybody knows if you’ve got the park that’s going to circle back to the chosen somehow. But I will watch this episode. I’m going to go watch this episode again tonight in light of what you just shared because I’d never noticed it, but they do a beautiful job. It’s like season two, episode four or five somewhere in there of the man who Jesus heals to walk and they tell his whole back story. As a child, they tell you, No, it’s fictional at that level, but that scene, when he is healed and he is jumping, and I never thought about it from the way you just said it, though, I was like, Yeah, he should have had to start walking slowly or something and like, No, it was immediate. And that’s how it
David McAlvany: gets to Luke. It’s important to Luke because as a doctor, he’s like, No, no, no, you don’t get this. This doesn’t happen. It just doesn’t happen. You don’t get to leave.
William Norvell: There’s no rehab. It’s just immediate, right? And gosh, you know, if you want to see a visual representation of that, it’s it’s beautiful how they portray it.
David McAlvany: The Chosen.
Henry Kaestner: OK, David, thank you. You’ve blessed us. I’m so grateful that you came up and talked to me at that lunch after the morning episode. I’m a richer man for it. Definitely. Figuratively, maybe literally. You know, you think you made a good case for gold? So just grateful for you as a brother and Christ, somebody who would take time with our audience to share with us all about a whole bunch of different things and just can’t wait to have you back.
David McAlvany: Well, thanks. It’s great to participate in a broader conversation, and I’m excited about what you guys are doing. Thanks for inviting me in.
Episode 103 – Resilient Leadership in a World of Constant Disruption with David Ridely
Subscribe to the Podcast:







David Ridley knows a thing or two about real estate investing. Not only did he found and lead Invesco Real Estate for 27 years, but he also helped grow it into one of the largest and most diversified real estate investment firms in the world. And while the numbers are staggering, what is most impressive about David was his steadfast leadership. Learn more about building a resilient team in a world of constant disruption, what it takes to be salt and light in a big company, and what hope we have for the future.
All opinions expressed on this podcast, including the team and guests, are solely their opinions. Host and guests may maintain positions in the companies and securities discussed. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as specific investment advice for any individual or organization.
Episode Transcript
Transcription is done by an AI software. While technology is an incredible tool to automate this process, there will be misspellings and typos that might accompany it. Please keep that in mind as you work through it.
John Coleman: Welcome to the Faith Driven Investor podcast. I’m John Coleman here with my partner, Luke Roush, and today we have the privilege of welcoming David Ridley to the show. Hi, David.
David Ridley: Hello there, John.
John Coleman: Well, I have to tell you, I’m really excited about this one. So I’ve known David for around a decade now. David was the founder and CEO of Invesco Real Estate, which grew to be a more than $60 billion real estate platform. Global everywhere in the world spanned tons of different products, and he also was just a great advocate for clients at the firm and someone that I considered a close friend and mentor. And so it’s really a privilege to have him on today. And we’re excited to learn how to build a $60 billion real estate platform. David, that should be a pretty easy task for you in the next 30 minutes or so. Is that right?
David Ridley: All right.
John Coleman: Well, talk to us a little bit about how you got started. We’d love to hear more about your life story as we dove in and just how you got into real estate investing.
David Ridley: You know, John, that’s good question. Because when I graduated with my finance degree from the University of Texas, nineteen seventy five, I had no idea what I wanted to do. But the one thing I did know I didn’t want to do is real estate. I wanted to be in stocks and bonds and all those really neat things. And somehow, the Lord has a sense of humor and shoehorned me right in the real estate. So it was kind of by accident. But if you don’t mind, I’ll just give you a little background on myself. I was born in San Antonio and my dad had been a B-17 pilot in the war and everything was new, you know, and he was the first out of eight that had ever gone to college. So we ended up getting transferred around a bit, and it was destiny that we’d moved back to Dallas because my mom died when I was nine and dad wanted to get us back or there was family. So it was just me and dad and my sister moved away to go to college. She might as well. That’s why I ended up down there, I think. And being with my dad all that time, he was pretty hardened guy. You know, he did. There wasn’t a lot of child-bearing books back then. I don’t believe he was a believer when he died as well. I hope he was, but he would tell me over and over. We’d be driving down the road and he’d see someone digging a ditch or working on a telephone pole. And he would say, Son, do you want to do that when you grow up? And he would just start beating into me. I was going to college. And so that was my beginning. So there’s one thing I knew I was going to do if nothing else in life, I was going to one day pass away, but I was going to pass away with college degree. So that’s how I happened, and I went down to UT and got out and came back and was fortunate enough to get into a management training program of a small life insurance company. And I went through this all the different departments, and they liked me enough in the real estate group that they hired me there. And so I started off on our biggest deal I think I ever did was like eight hundred thousand dollars on a warehouse and that it was a good start.
John Coleman: It was faith always important to you, David, or when did that become a part of your life?
David Ridley: You know, growing up without a mother and dad was never at home? OK, so that was good for me. I thought that was fantastic, but I was without any real great leadership and there was this woman down the block who had three of the most beautiful sisters you’ve ever seen, who I really thought were cute and a son that I played in my little football teams with an elementary school right through high school with Danny. And that woman was a godly woman and she prayed for me constantly. And so sophomore year comes around, I was getting in more trouble. Junior year was no better and I finally thought I’ve had it. Friend of mine asked me to read the Bible. I opened it up and it made sense. For the first time in my life, I understood the value of Christ’s sacrifice. And I prayed that night in bed between my junior and senior year that he would come into my life, and it was a remarkable change for me, and I jumped out of bed and drove over to her house the next morning to let her know. And she was a godly woman, and someone I think about constantly changed me forever.
John Coleman: That’s fantastic, David. And as you navigated, you mentioned you didn’t really want to get into real estate. You want to get into anything but real estate. So how did you end up in real estate?
David Ridley: Well, there was a program where you rotated throughout the company, and one of those was a real estate area and there was an Aggie in there and that Aggie decided he wanted to go back to College Station and open some ice cream stores. So I had written a really nice note. My dad had taught me to to do back in the low tech days, telling them how much I enjoyed it and that department. I’d done that earlier. So when he quit, they invited me down.
Speaker 3: And David, you know, maybe just for purposes of just listeners who were trying to get a sense of scope and scale, maybe share a bit about that. In terms of what your work in Invesco became, but maybe also speak to kind of why you went about that work and creation of jobs and sort of other things, it was a clear motivating factor for you.
David Ridley: What happened was that was my start in my career was south of life. I was fortunate enough to be hired by a large insurance company called Metropolitan Life, and they had their top person in the investment area, come to Dallas and made a little speech to us and told us where the world was trending. And it was towards managing other people’s money. OK? He said. The trillions of dollars that are out there, the investable dollars are located in pension funds, endowments, foundations, sovereign wealth funds, et cetera, et cetera. Well, that planted a seed in me that I wanted to be part of that. And so as fate would have it, this company, I was making a little bit of a reputation for myself and Dallas, and this company that had been around a long time in Dallas invited me over to start that kind of group. So I started it from scratch. It was me and a secretary. No clients, no money under management. They had a relationship with Texas teachers. They were impressed enough to give us a chance to be one of the firms that would do that for them. And that’s how it started. You know, they were OK with my qualifications. We got a contract signed and we had a nondiscretionary relationship with one of the toughest staffs I’ve ever had. And that’s how the thing got started. But it was tough. There were 10 years with only one client in. The worst thing about it was we had no idea how to get another one. Okay. And and so that’s how I got started. It was a very humbling experience, to say the least, competing against all the big boys, JP Morgan, Morgan Stanley. Some of these firms, you don’t know, but Reif and some other ones back then. So I don’t know where you want me to go from there, but I’ll tell you it was a it was a rough start.
John Coleman: Well, talk to us a little bit about that journey, David, because I’ve heard this story before and just how you came to Invesco, your interactions with Charlie. And then, you know, as I remember, there was a pivotal point in the history of the business where you decided that you couldn’t do it on your own and I’d love to hear you just tell that story as well.
David Ridley: Yeah. So I remember sitting on the kitchen counter trying to decide if I was going to make this move and start this firm. And Candy’s 80 year old grandmother was sitting there in the kitchen and she goes, David, in 30 years, it will take a bit of difference. So that was she really started this, I guess. So I jumped off the counter and drove my little purple opal down to downtown Dallas and joined the firm. And I had been into it for about two years. And when sort of this pivotal moment came, I’d been asked to come down to Houston by maybe one of their leading brokers. And I went down there and I looked at warehouses all day long in with her staff, and we were looking for investment opportunities all the time. And that night, at dinner, after dinner, I was trying to bond with these folks. So they bring me product and not others. The leader in that group, this powerful broker, kind of took his spoon and dinged the glass and he he sort of stopped the meeting and I thought he was going to say something nice. But he looked at us and looked specifically at me. And he says, David, what makes you think you have any chance to build this firm? Look, you’re competing against. And he started naming firms. And I was a bit in shock. And I remember chills run down my spine because I realized he was really right. I didn’t have much of a chance. If I’d really studied it harder, done a little more due diligence, I probably would have never tried it. And honestly, I don’t even remember the rest of that dinner. I just remember getting back to the hotel room and opening the door. I walked back to it. It was near the Galleria and there was this little wooden desk in the corner and I sat at that desk and I just wanted to cry about me and to ruin my career. I had a leadership position where I was. Maybe I can get my job back, but that’s not going to happen. So I took a pad of paper and I wrote down and I filled up every line with my weaknesses. Why this was impossible. I wasn’t smart enough. I didn’t know how to sell myself, you know, just on and on, and I took that sheet of paper and I put it on the floor and I got down on my hands and knees and put my forehead on it. I remember that, and I just prayed Lord, first, would you just take me out of this job and move me? But if you don’t want to move me, then you be CEO and I’ll be doorman or whatever else you want me to do here. But I’m done. And that went on for a while, and I stood up from that floor and I’ve never had this feeling in my life, just like someone took a thousand pounds and lifted it off, my back flew back to Dallas the next morning, creativity returned and just optimism. I had no fear of failure. I wanted to do well for all these senior people at this company, but I literally had no fear of failure any more. It wasn’t mine to lose. And that changed everything in the way God showed up was. He started introducing me to these people, John, that you know, that three of me retired with me and we went all the way together. And you know, finding people is almost impossible. The right people. And I couldn’t do it. Up to that point. So he tangibly showed up with these folks that we were able to team up with and do some great things. So I would say that we’re in the middle of writing a book and there’s three pillars in that book and in the first one has to do with being securely centered, and I will tell you that securely centered me for the next thirty two years. So it was a pivotal moment for me, John.
Luke Roush: When you talk about being securely centered, maybe just speak a little bit to what that looks like in the context of thirty two years at a big company like Invesco. What does it look like to be securely centered and kind of salt and light where you’re planted?
David Ridley: You know, tangibly, you can see it because. You don’t have the warning signs would be anxiety, insecurity, you know, comparing yourself to others. All those things. And when I speak to college students, I call those the big sins in business for a believer. And even when I’m speaking secularly, so all those went away, I immediately hired two people. One of them, I paid twice as much as me. And the other was David Farmer. Johnny, you remember I paid him like a quarter more than me, and it was about finding the right talent that could produce the right results for these clients and for our people that we were going to work for and have worked with us. And so that’s what it looked like. And to be secure in myself, you know? Yeah. And that helped move us into building a culture that was somewhat maybe unparalleled in our sector.
John Coleman: Yeah, talk about that a little bit more, David, because I’ve heard you talk about just the importance of your partners, the people, the culture that you built in. I’ve also even seen you tell this story, this story about that hotel room and really handing things over to God and in the workplace that you were really authentic about the way in which that transformed you. I’d love to hear how you started to build that culture, how you found those people and how your partnership evolved in a way that was so powerful.
David Ridley: You know, it was all experiential. John, I didn’t have any textbooks that talked about this. So. So first of all, let me say, I’m probably the least likely CEO you’ll ever meet. OK. My favorite verse talks about where Paul asked for his thorn to be removed or whatever that was, and God said, No, my grace is made strong in your weakness, and I’ve always known that I’ve always kept that promise close to my heart. So I didn’t go into this thinking I was the smartest guy in the room by any stretch of the imagination. So once I was centered, it was easy for me to realize that I needed to gather the best athletes around me, but also we needed to build great teams. We had to have great. We call it extreme team engagement. You know, as God has created us to do life with others, we call that other ring. And so I knew that was going to be key to us being able to win and have a healthy business. And so, you know, I happened to read, in fact, I’d left Invesco when I read this. I wish I’d known it when I was there, but it was St. Augustine in the fourth century, had a quote. It said humility is the foundation of all the other virtues. Hence the soul for that virtue does not exist. There can be no others except in mere appearance. And so when we would go out to build these teams, we would look for true humility. It was easy to find talent. It was hard to find humility in someone who could fit in. So we’d look for humility. We’d look for a team orientation as opposed to a star system. Then we try to find folks with a fire in their belly so that, you know, they get things done. And like you, John, you always walk around fast and get things done, and that’s what we needed. So from being centered, I was able to go find those kind of people who I thought were better than I was and I was able to empower them. That’s the biggest gift you can give. Anyone is empowerment. I learned that from a billionaire real estate guy in Dallas. I’m sure he’s a Christian, but he would get his key leaders in the room and he would ask them questions that I knew he knew the answers to. So I started doing that. I would let them be the experts. I just became the bandleader, the coordinator. And that enabled some folks to really grow and thrive. And we ended up with some great team play there, which resulted in a great culture which becomes your character in the marketplace. People know you for that. In the business case, for it is you end up with high stability. We never lost a partner. We never lost a client. Knock on wood, high stability of people and clients. That’s hard to replicate. You know when you’re competing.
Luke Roush: So David, as you kind of went from building the team kind of world class, humble individuals that had both fire in the belly, but also a servant’s mentality? And it wasn’t about them. It was about the mission that you guys were on together. Maybe just talk a little bit about moving from building the team to building the portfolio of investments, a lot of capital to work over time and then maybe just extend off of kind of what that look like BAM to the market today and what’s changed, maybe since you were running that group at Invesco?
David Ridley: Well, that’s a great question. Basically, one of the pivotal moments was a trip I made to Atlanta. We had just orchestrated a sale of our firm to Invesco. This was 1990. I flew over to Atlanta as a Saturday morning. I remembered and opened my book up the show. Charlie Brady, the founder of Invesco, What we were going to do to be successful. And it was this strategic multifamily investment program in the South. You know, it was all this. And we’re sitting there, his myself and a fellow named David Farmer, and he reached over right in the middle of my pitch. He just closed the book and I kind of looked at him with, Oh my god. That can’t be a good sign in any culture. And he says, David, listen to me. He goes, This is all great. I’ve been very impressed with your diligence in how you run your business. And, you know, he went on about things that he likes. But he said, You do understand if you can’t win, none of this makes any difference. None of this matters. And I began to realize at that moment my life, he’s right. We have to learn to win. So once you build great teams, it’s about having a healthy environment. We just talked about that. If you’re not winning as part of those factors, if one of them in winning, then you’re done. So that taught us the importance of this elite client engagement that we had to get really great at which we did. And I’ve got to tell you the way that happened. We were armed with great people. We developed something called the war room. We have the culture to do it. When we found out who our competitors were, we’d go in that war room and we would literally we had a structure where we knew more about those competitors, maybe, than they knew about themselves. And we juxtapose those strengths and weaknesses against our own. We would figure out ways to be more competitive. Part of having a great firm is the ability to have great meetings, and we had great meetings. We had rules of the room. You had to check your ego at the door. There was no rank in the room. If you’re at the table, we had an obligation to disagree. You know when you needed to, then when you left the room, your friends and those are the rules, and we had the most robust group meetings around winning. And they worked. And so we started. Once we got this together, it was all about having a value proposition that made sense, etc. Just absolutely amazing preparation. And once we got all that together, we just started winning clients. It was amazing. We went from one client to the first one was state of Nevada and went on and went to Los Angeles County, then Colorado. I remember almost crying on the phone. I had to hide my tears from the guy there in Colorado because I never thought we’d get a second client, much less a third one. So, yeah, that’s how we started winning. And it was around having a healthy environment where people could be empowered and grow. And it’s just a more holistic approach, and it’s not a secret anymore. McKinsey has studied this thousands of companies, and they determine firms that focus on their culture, meaning their health in factors that cause great cultures are four times more successful than firms that focus more on their acquisition or their ability to execute and operate. They’re just more important if they’re focusing on those things equally with those operational executional things. So we just happen to really get that.
John Coleman: David, that was one of the more fascinating things about the culture that you built. I remember and I’ve told the story elsewhere. You know, when you’d walk into your offices in Dallas right behind the reception desk, there was a big painting that had firefighters and teachers and police officers on it because those were your clients. Those were the beneficiaries of these public funds that were investing with y’all. And there was a real sense in your group at Invesco Real Estate that the clients really mattered and that that’s why you were there and that’s the purpose of what you were doing. It wasn’t just winning with clients, it was winning for clients and making sure that you were guardians of the capital that they were entrusting you with. Where did that come from for you and how did you instill that in everybody at the company?
David Ridley: You know everything. And you know this, everything comes down from leadership. So as a leader, it’s all going to reflect you. And that was a little bit of it, to be honest, was my natural personality. But what really honed this was having one non-discretionary client for 10 years that shaped us, man. There were many, many of our competitors that had commingled funds. They had hundreds of clients. They did not understand the servant’s heart that it took to satisfy one high demanding client for 10 years. So the only way to quickly exit our firm would be to not get that in. If you didn’t have that characteristic about you, you would win yourself out really quickly. So that came down to this humble heart that we had with these clients, and we just couldn’t be wrong. You know, in the way we executed that. So we did have a servant heart and they got to know that they felt it and we developed accountability. So we called it the Invesco Report card. So it was all about building trust. It wasn’t about investing money, it was having trust built and then it was about investing money in high levels of accountability. And one thing that really helped us to continue winning back to that topic was we developed the postmortem process so that when we lost, we don’t get in that room within five. Days in, find out why we lost and no fingers could be pointed because we’re all very potential to lay down a stinker here and there, which I’m probably doing right now, John. But what was definitely very disciplined in the culture of clients or everything just sort of permeated that picture you talk about. We talked about that all the time in quarterly meetings that we would have and I would be speaking. We’d refer to that picture. And I’d ask everybody in the room, if you’re involved in sales and client engagement, raise your hand and everybody in the room had to raise their hand before we could go on with the meeting. Because, you know, the smart investment, people don’t want to be known as marketing people or client necessarily client people, and they had to be in our culture.
John Coleman: I have seen David stop many a meeting until every executive raise their hand for the who’s in sales question, so absolutely authentic. Any good stories about what that look like? David, I remember one that you told me about the Boy Scouts coming to Dallas, for example, but any great examples of how that looked in action?
David Ridley: Oh gosh, you know? Yeah, that Boy Scout one, I went around. I actually did a survey of all of our Dallas team anyway, and we have like 20 Eagle Scouts. I had no idea. I never made it past the Cub Scouts, so I was so happy to use that statistic. But it was the one of the toughest presentations we’ve ever had. And they were tough. They loved to ask the toughest questions in this time. They asked my colleague, who’s now our CEO and Invesco, the address of a property that we invested in his city and we didn’t know that address. We knew the basic block it was on. I remember leaving that thing and pounding my steering wheel. I was so mad that we blew it. You know, we didn’t make it, and there were always that tough, but we won the account, Praise Lord, and we ended up having them as a client. They were very tough and we would have to remind ourselves it doesn’t matter how tough they are, we’re here to serve them. And we would just break our back to do it. And you know, that’s the way it was. Clients never wrong, although sometimes they have to be steered around investment ideas that they were never wrong. You know,
Luke Roush: maybe just taking a moment to look out the front windshield of where you think the market is going. David Witter, just a couple of pieces of counsel that you would give to aspiring investors who were looking at current uncertainty in the market in the next 10 years. Just a couple of pieces of counsel that you would offer from your own experience.
David Ridley: Well, what I would say is I know I’ve lived in my business life. I’ve lived through seven recessions. Every everyone had a black swan event to it. None of them. Did anybody guess you can never forecast what that black swan is going to be the best ones? The GFC, you know, we suffered through the Great Recession in some way, and it’s been almost 11 years since we’ve had one. So I know it’s coming. The Black Swan is out there and it’s probably happening right now with this new war we’re engaged in. And every one of them is scary. But in my humble opinion, they all pass. And you have to look at it that way. You can’t change the gravitational things that you’re doing. And like everything, these three pillars we’re talking about, you have to stay consistent with those disciplines that you have. So anyway, it’s important to recognize they’re going to happen and how you’re prepared for them in our business. There’s lots of things that have changed, and I’m maybe not the expert anymore since I’ve been gone almost seven years. But but we all know what’s happened to office buildings. Obviously, a black swan was COVID, and that was a big hit when that hit us. Office buildings are not nearly occupied like they were Amazon and others came along and changed. Retailing that’s left us primarily with industrial and multifamily is the darlings of the investment space these days that’s taken our camp rights, which are the first. That’s how you measure returns at your first year’s return in real estate. It’s taken out to historic lows in my earlier career. In fact, a friend of mine even wrote a paper. The answer is nine. OK, you bought real estate on a nine. And I remember seeing somebody took an eight and seven return on something, and I thought they were crazy. They were not correlated to treasuries. It was incredible. So now you’ve got the most expensive apartments in industrial properties you’ve ever seen out there. So people are having to lean into different things to satisfy clients. And some of those things are like medical office buildings look better than they’ve ever looked self-storage even residential mortgages or being, you know, all this, but through various conduits. The problem with those was bite size. But now invest goes into joint venture of some kind that they’re able to buy the bigger tranches of that loans now making lots of loans. It’s not your traditional money center bank anymore, your insurance company, there’s a lot of loans that our guys are making a private rate they formed to get to the retail markets. So all that’s new since I left. So every year, you know, it’s change and they laugh at me now they say, you couldn’t even work over here anymore, Dave. You wouldn’t know what’s going on. And I say, you’re probably right. You’re always having to change and be flexible.
Luke Roush: Well, the funny thing is that on the one hand, some of the facts and circumstances change. But part of what I take away from your commentary is that the most important thing? Rings around team, why you do what you do, how you care for clients. Those are more timeless principles than they are. Timely facts and circumstances are timely that core things are usually timeless.
David Ridley: I call them gravitational there things that have never changed in my career. I remember getting in before the Sun came up and talking about how we’re going to win clients and who we were going to be. And I remember making decisions that are still good decisions today, but one was we were not going to focus on any one property type. We were going to be the four main food groups which I won’t bore you with. We were not going to be a southwestern exposure. We were going to be national and that turned into global. We were not going to be one risk level. We were going to be up the scale from poor real estate to value added to opportunistic. And we didn’t want any clients having more than like five or 10 percent of our business, and we got that done eventually. When I started, we had one client who 100 percent so all those things are good business disciplines, but we got there, in my opinion, more predictably because of the disciplines around the three pillars. It’s building that kind of culture, and it’s the soft stuff that some people don’t understand that keeps them in marginalizes them towards not being able to be a really great, larger competitor.
John Coleman: And David, I know you’ve been up to some really interesting stuff lately, you’ve been kind of retired, I guess, although you’ve transitioned to some other things before we do that. You know, there are a lot of folks listening to this podcast who like you exist in larger, diverse organizations with all different types of people, and you led a large, diverse organization where people of different faiths or no faith at all. What advice would you have to those in those organizations about living their faith authentically in those types of diverse environments that aren’t necessarily faith based or faith driven?
David Ridley: You know, that’s a great question. I was convinced, you know, I mentioned that godly woman. Her name is Nelda Hassall. You know, when I first found the Lord in was saying I had my four spiritual laws book and I went to airports, I went all over the place in witnessing, and that’s not wrong. You know, that was a very rewarding thing. But as a CEO in a multi-faith company and so forth, you obviously can’t do that. So what Nelda had told me even back then, she says, you need to pray that God will bring people into your life that he wants you talking to. You need to just relax and pray that the Lord will open those doors. And so I’ve always had that feeling that that’s what I needed to do, and God has been good about doing that. So we didn’t go out to find just Christians. We went out to find the best talent we could in the lower stamp. As they interview people, they could see they’re really talented. Our job in the upper management was to figure out who they were, really personally, who their culture was and how were they humble as we talked about it and all those things? And it didn’t matter if they’re Christians. We ended up with a lot of Christians. But my feeling was it was to be salt light. And people knew who we were in our hearts. We wouldn’t hide it, but we didn’t put it on our sleeve and try to push it. There was a woman out in California, I was told the other day by our new CEO. He said she almost didn’t join us because she thought we were a Christian organization. And I thought, Well, that’s funny because we’ve never advertised ourselves as being a Christian organization, but people can see your values and who you are, and maybe sometimes it seeps through. But our job is to our people, first in our clients, then the stockholders benefit in our obligation is to have great people in that we can get great clients with who will then benefit our stockholders. And I was fortunate to lead one of my bosses to Christ, once you know, I mean, it does happen, but it’s not something that was on the front end.
John Coleman: And David, you’ve kind of taken a lot of the lessons you learned building a company over the course of a few decades, and you’re now talking to others about those. And I hear you even have a book coming together. Do you mind talking about kind of what’s happened after Invesco Real Estate and what you’re up to today?
David Ridley: Well, we traveled. We had a lot of fun. We went to. I’ve never been to Italy, believe it or not, we even had an office there and I’d never been there. But we just had a ball and one day candy and I looked at each other and we said, we’re so done with traveling. You know, I and 10 million miles on just American, you know, during my business life. So we settled down and my prayer was, I’m not going to go look for presentations, but I’m going to be open to do it. So Lord appeal, please open the right doors. And he did that through a couple of organizations. I started speaking the college students and I love doing that. I love. For twenty five years or more, I’ve been mentoring young business people. Now it’s college students and young business people, and that’s where I really find satisfaction now. Have I consulted? Yeah, I’m affiliated with, I should say. I guess I collaborate with Dr. Chip Roper, a brilliant man out of New York who is called out of the pastor who’s business in 20 years as a pastor, then called back to New York City from Philadelphia to minister to Christian executives. And we met each other, and together we’re putting a book together. It’s called resilient leadership. At this point, who knows what it will be called building winning teams in the face of constant disruption. I kind of like to think about it is leading without regrets. I kind of like that title because what I wanted to do, I’d always watch Southwest Airlines and Herb Kelleher, and I would see how he led without regrets. I don’t know that he was a Christian, but he really loved his people. And I can tell you when you retire, your legacy that you leave behind is about 100 times more important to you than you know it is or will be now. And so you want to leave behind people who knew that you love them and really feel great about the way you treated them and where there later. And so that’s what drives me and I want to write. I spoke with Chip, not necessarily for me, John, as I said earlier to you, it’s really, I think, going to give him legs as he builds his consulting business, which I participate some of those consulting assignments, but he’s got more to play for here than I do. So, hey, John, I think you’ll recognize my bio. You clean that up, buddy.
John Coleman: David was good at living the right life, and I was good at editing.
David Ridley: Yeah, I sent John my bio, and I think after he got up off the floor laughing, he rewrote it. I’m still using it over here.
Luke Roush: David, I think maybe the reverse that you were looking for earlier was, is it Second Corinthians 12 nine? Yeah, he said to me, my grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness. Therefore, I will boost all the more gladly about my weaknesses so that Christ Power may rest on me. And just as you shared some about your career and just the humility that you do that with, it’s clear and where you find power from. So I’m grateful for you taking some time, and I’ll turn it over to John to wrap this up.
John Coleman: Yes, Sir David will have to ask one question as we close out and then any parting thoughts from you. And that’s just what is God been teaching you recently? And how has he been speaking to you?
David Ridley: You know, re impressing upon me the importance of habits that you need to stay with, and that means meeting with a coach before the game. And that’s getting up every day and spending my first 30 minutes with Christ and how importance obedience is in the fruits of obedience. To walk in life with a spirit filled mine takes obedience. It takes being obedient to God and listening to the Holy Spirit and staying with those disciplines. And so I’ve really had to work. You know, it was easier when I was working, frankly, to have those routines than now. So he’s been teaching me a lot about that and about being available, you know, and not stopping the mentoring and being available for consulting when someone calls on me, etc. So it’s a great life to be able to have time to actually do that and not have to punch a clock. You know that the powerful
John Coleman: that’s powerful, David. That’s awesome. And look, we are really grateful to have been able to talk to you today. I know I personally am really grateful for the example you set in the real estate industry and at the firm I used to work at and just the friendship that we’ve had over the years. And I know that this will be a great benefit to all those out there who are thinking about starting their own firms, folks like my partner who went through their own decade long process of building businesses just like you. So thank you for taking the time to spend with us today.
David Ridley: Yeah, it’s been a pleasure. I’m highly flattered. You reach out to me.
Luke Roush: No brainer. Grateful for you, David. Blessings to you and appreciate your time.
Episode 104 – Biblically Responsible Investing with Robert Netzly
Subscribe to the Podcast:







Robert Netzly is a globally recognized authority in the Biblically Responsible Investing movement and author of the Amazon #1 best-selling book “Biblically Responsible Investing”. He is the Founder and CEO of Inspire Investing, a leading innovator in providing low cost, high impact, biblically responsible investing solutions to institutions, advisors, and investors. Robert is a frequent contributor on FOX Business, Bloomberg, New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, The Financial Times, The Christian Post and other major global media for his thought leadership in the faith-based, environmental, social and governance (ESG) investing marketplace. Today, Robert joins us to talk about key aspects of Biblically responsible investing, what it means to be an active and engaged shareholder, and how your faith is reflected in the way we shepherd our capital.
All opinions expressed on this podcast, including the team and guests, are solely their opinions. Host and guests may maintain positions in the companies and securities discussed. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as specific investment advice for any individual or organization.
Episode Transcript
Transcription is done by an AI software. While technology is an incredible tool to automate this process, there will be misspellings and typos that might accompany it. Please keep that in mind as you work through it.
Henry Kaestner: Welcome back to the Faith Driven Investor podcast, Luke. Great to be doing this with you.
Luke Roush: It is great to be on. It’s good to be on with Robert again.
Henry Kaestner: It is. It is, is great. In the last episode we had done. I recall that I talked about my very limited economics, background and capability at the University of Delaware. I just kind of stumbling through micro and macro as I was spending more of my time selling T-shirts. But I didn’t ask you about your background, and I don’t know that anybody knows on the podcast that you actually study public policy at Duke. You must have had economics at some point in time. Right?
Luke Roush: Me, absolutely. Yeah, there’s a lot of it more than I’d like to remember, but I really enjoyed it, particularly the micro, because you can kind of get your arms around it and you get to see it every day.
Henry Kaestner: Yeah, yeah. OK, so speaking of economics, we have a guy that we’ve had on. This may be their first repeat customer on the Faith Driven Investor podcast, and we’ve got Robert Nazli in the house. And Robert has been a great friend of the movement and has been an inspiration to us and that he’s gone out and launched a firm against all odds, finding a need in the market and really just really launching something really special. We’ve had you on before, Robert, and where you gave a little bit of a longer biographical sketch, but I want to revisit some of that too. Who are you? Where do you come from? What is inspire?
Robert Netzly: Yeah, it is good to be back. And if I am the first be customer, wow, what an honor. I think unless you just can’t find another guest to be on here. And then so, you know, it’s absolutely one of those things. Yeah, no. My economic background consists of learning how to grow up on food stamps with a single mother with a younger brother who is autistic. And, you know, parents, you know, went through the 70 drug scene and everything and just not, you know, a typical background that you might think of as a business leader went to community college and dropped out my junior year, you know, done all kinds of different things along the way. A lot of ministry, you know, at our local church that we kind of helped start up back in the day and somehow by God’s grace ended up in the investment industry and really took to it, you know, so that’s my background, you know, in a nutshell, but I’m certainly not the guy you would have picked in high school or junior high or anything else is like, Hey, this is this is the guy who is going to start an investment firm. I got D’s in math, hated public speaking, and here I am, talking to lots of people about money. So there you go.
Luke Roush: Well, you know, the concept of biblically responsible investing is really something that you helped really to initiate, maybe to share a bit more about that and then maybe how the movement has evolved over time.
Robert Netzly: Yeah. And I certainly didn’t invent the idea, for sure. You know, my professional background was at Wells Fargo Private Client Service. Working out in Carmel, California really is happy as a clam there and then of learning how to do math and learning how to talk to people again by God’s grace. But then I stumbled across this whole concept of biblically responsible investing online one day. This idea that you’re not just looking at the financial returns of a portfolio, but you know, God probably cares about the kinds of companies we’re investing in. Are these companies manufacturing abortion drugs or selling pornography or violating human rights in their supply chains? What are these companies doing? What are you doing as an owner to profit from these things? And what does the Bible have to say about that? So that’s that’s typically responsible investing. When I first looked into that, I honestly the Holy Spirit has gripped my heart because here I was president of our local pro-life pregnancy center at the time, and I discovered I owned stocks in three companies that manufacture abortion drugs and got hit me upside the head with the fact that every time that young lady goes across the street has an abortion. Planned Parenthood. I just made money in that transaction. I literally profited, recommending all my clients to do the same thing, and that was my intro to biblically responsible investing.
Luke Roush: It was there. Was there a moment in time where all of a sudden or maybe an experience where you realized, like, I need to leave wells, I need to start a firm? You know, oftentimes in that formation story of a company, there’s some sort of injustice or something that’s, you know, just broken in the world that you feel called to fix. Let me speak a little bit to kind of that catalytic zero to one moment.
Robert Netzly: Yep, and it came really quick. Once I again stumbled across this realization, I just I could not do my job with a clean conscience anymore. In two weeks time, I was just dead in the water, which was, you know, troubling because I didn’t know if I could even stay in the business. I’ve never met anybody doing what we do now. I have no conception that there is even something else going on in the industry, you know, in other places, in a Christian sense. So I went home, told my wife, Hey, honey, I think the God’s call somewhere else, and I need to work somewhere else in a different industry. And here’s what I found. And she’s like, Well, we got two babies in the mortgage. So what’s the plan? Right? And ended up just was this close to going to seminary? I was honestly in conversations with multiple seminaries, and like that was I was just going to do a pastor thing. And the only way I could think of staying in the business was, well, I suppose I could, you know, leave the bank start an independent firm that only did some sort of. Look, gold type, you know, investing, but that’s crazy, because I don’t have the experience or money or connections or, you know, all the things that you’re supposed to have before you do something like that. But as we prayed as God does, he just made it unmistakably clear through a number of ways. But the compulsion was just undeniable that that’s exactly what I was supposed to do. So two months later made the incredibly frightening decision to leave the bank left my clients there with a team I’d been with previously started over or just need a laptop. Less than two months of savings, the bank fully prepared never to pay my mortgage ever again in my life and fully convicted. This is exactly what God is calling me to do. It doesn’t mean it’s going to be financially successful, so maybe I’ll go broke in six months and move on to the family with my mom and whatever and then go to seminary. But whatever God like this is your plan. I know this is your call in my life and I’ve got to obey. So that was, you know, a little over 10 years ago. So while the think
Henry Kaestner: Robert, one of the things that you’ve talked about a bunch is what does it look like to engage with companies and be kind of an activist shareholder? Having some skin in the game? Being a shareholder affords you a different opportunities to be able to witness and be heard. Talk to us a little bit about what that looks like in the investing you all do.
Robert Netzly: Yeah, and this is again, I mean, it was accidental almost that this whole business started. I got into this industry and then really sort of fell into this idea of shareholder engagement wasn’t something that was on our, you know, business plan to do. But as we, you know, as guidance really grew this business from those early days and started opening our eyes to there’s more Christians in this industry that God is doing the same sort of work in their hearts. It wasn’t mine and looking for ways to do this. It just became evident that there is a larger voice that needs to be shared with corporate America. And these companies were investing in, you know, occasionally a quote good company will sort of get off the rails or something. And now we got to dump some out of our portfolio or think of, you know, do something there. And I think the first time that we had a conversation around this idea was a friend of ours in the industry. Another Christian financial advisor was working with Chevron, kind of engaging with them to stop giving money to Planned Parenthood. They’ve been donating money to Planned Parenthood, and we live near the Chevron headquarters in the Silicon Valley area. And so he asked, You know, can we attend this meeting and stuff like, sure. And so you end up going to this meeting and happy story. Chevron stopped donating money to Planned Parenthood and, you know, the short version of that story. And that led us to sort of think of, well, what other companies might we engage with? And so over this time, when we’ve seen things at a business that we’re invested in or we like to invest in a business that needs a little help, we just pick up the phone and call investor relations, send an e-mail. Investor Relations and we’ve had amazing success that we never thought we would with many companies, huge companies that are actually interested in hearing from all of their investors, including faith based investors. And oftentimes are very receptive to integrating the feedback they hear from us into their business practices. So it’s been really encouraging and it’s become a bigger part of our business and kind of day to day here it inspire.
Luke Roush: So you’re kind of describing, you know, and this concept of kind of negative screening, positive screening, active engagement, which you’re kind of describing, is that third bucket. Maybe you speak a little bit to kind of how you’ve seen bride evolve over time along all three dimensions of how people might think about their faith being reflected in how they shepherd capital.
Robert Netzly: Yeah, I think historically the exclude part of that equation has been the starting point, going back decades and decades, and it’s absolutely essential. I mean, I do believe strongly converted from the word of God that it’s just like I should not, as a Christian, be making money from abortions, right? And a number of other things. So we have to be looking at the exclusionary criteria in our portfolios. But then we go beyond that. And really, the nexus of inspire and Inspire was this idea that well, in addition to excluding where the most glorifying companies, I mean, there’s companies out there that they’re not necessarily Christian or run explicitly by Christians or Christian values, but they’re operating in line with God’s principles like fairness and morality and ethics and things like that, right? Surprise, surprise. And I wonder if we could measure the relative biblical alignment of companies and then invest in those most biblically aligned companies. You know, the most inspiring, positive companies that are creating products that are blessings of people that use them, that have policies and practices that just bless their employees, that bless the communities they operate in a lot of different specific ways. And so we created what we call our Inspire Impact Score methodology, which is just our rules based approach to scoring companies from a negative hundreds of positive 100. We invest in anything above zero, anything below zero we exclude. But really, we’re looking for those highest scoring companies as a real, faith based approach to environmental, social and governance investing ESG. And that’s been a big trend as we’re seeing more investors. Is sort of ride the coattails of a broadly secular, you know, progressively secular, oftentimes ESG movement in the industry and say, Hey, you know, the Bible talks about environment, the Bible talks about social, the Bible talks about governance. What about a biblical worldview on those issues from a positive perspective? So we invest in those highest rated companies from a biblical lens in those categories? And then the third is that engagement where we have this, you know, as investors, we have an opportunity to call the companies that we invest in. We can file shareholder resolutions and get involved in proxies. If you want to or just very casually just off the books to have conversations, say, Hey, you know, I’m an investor, I’m a Christian, I care about certain things and you know, x y z like, please don’t give money to Planned Parenthood. That’s something that I don’t really want my company doing. Here’s why. In a number of other issues. So that’s that exclude, endorse, engage sort of framework that we use here to inspire. And we’re seeing a lot of other faith based asset managers and wealth managers get more involved in that, which is really exciting to think. You know, as Christians, as the industry, there’s a lot of money 20 trillion dollars plus that are controlled by Protestants, evangelicals and Catholics in this country alone. Stocks, bonds, mutual funds. That’s a lot of capital that can have a lot of influence if we just are intentional with those conversations.
Henry Kaestner: One of the things I want to do is just go off script just a little bit. We’ve got a great carryover audience with Faith Driven Entrepreneur and you are a Faith Driven Entrepreneur. You’ve seen an opportunity, a problem to be solved. You’ve leaned into it, you’ve created a business around it, a business that has grown very rapidly. What’s it like just to navigate through all that? As you know, your interview by The Wall Street Journal or The New York Times, all of a sudden the spotlights on you and the more influence you have, the more critics you have. What’s that ride been like for the last five years?
Robert Netzly: Unexpected as everything else, and to flesh that out a little bit. Yeah, I mean, from the moment I left Wells Fargo and started talking to clients about this concept, it was obviously God was at work, people’s jaws at the floor, their eyes opened like, Wow, I’ve never thought about this before. How do I invest this way? I had to bring other advisors into the practice, not my plan. The influence and business just started growing, and I have no business training background, as I alluded to, and it’s been failing forward fast and trying to keep up with what God is doing. So there’s a whole lot of learning on the fly. A whole lot of build the airplane before you hit the ground, FDE jump off the cliff and all of those analogies that entrepreneurs are aware of. Our particular story around 2015 is when we started aspire as a standalone company and realize that there’s more of an industry and we need to create some products like our exchange traded funds and other asset manager products to really serve the financial advisors that we’re trying to go all in for God’s glory in the practice. But there was a dearth of, you know, product availability. And so in 2017, we ended up launching the first two ETFs in the New York Stock Exchange on a wing, a prayer hole, up top ramen beans and rice, you know, months without salary. Small, committed team that just knew that. We knew that. We knew that God was calling us to do this, and we had to bring this to market because God’s people need to be empowered to invest for us, and they weren’t empowered to do that. And so by God’s grace, we lost this to its 10 year goal ended up being like a one year goal somehow. And the next day, we’re yeah in the New York Times, on the front page of the business section in The Wall Street Journal. All these other hundreds of articles and interviews later, just trial by fire and what we’ve really learned from that process. Obviously, what we’re standing for is not really well embraced by many people in our world these days, and we’ve been called lots of names, you know, for believing things about the Bible. But we’ve just been encouraged also that there’s such an outpouring of support from people who do love God and do believe the Bible and are just so thankful that first week I got a Twitter message from a gentleman in Zambia and he was just gushing and saying how he’s been praying for us ever since he heard the news of the New York Times and that he bought shares in our ETFs in Zambia. You know that very first week we were trading, you know this hundreds, literally hundreds of other stories like that. So we’ve been incredibly encouraged that this is a work that God is doing. He is opening the eyes of his people all over the world, literally that he cares about how we manage his money and that when you step out in faith to follow God and something he’s calling you to do, he’s not going to let you get just get run over by the bus, right and say, Oh, sorry, you thought you were following my instructions, but you made a wrong turn? Sorry. Now he either protects us by correcting us when we do make those missteps or encourages on those correct steps that correct direction. But if you’re stepping out in faith, you can’t make a wrong step is the point. You’re not always going to have success when actually you’re not always going to, you know, avoid problems, but God will be with you, and he will take you through those things and faithfully follow his leading through prayer to the world through intensive to the Holy Spirit. Direction your life. Without a doubt, we would not be here if it was us trying to figure out a business plan. This has been trying to follow God’s leading in our life as a business. A lot of times as counterintuitive. A lot of times it flies against the business convention. We got a lot of advice from a lot of smart people who got decades of industry experience that our idea was terrible and we were going to be miserable failures. Some of them were Christians, but we just knew God was calling us to do it. And it’s not bad and thankfully miserable failure. You know, we were managing about $2 billion of assets right now or the third fastest growing registered investment advisory firm in the nation, two years running in 5000 top quartile. Like all glory to God because this was not our plan. And he is just doing a work and we’re trying to keep up and be faithful. That’s the calling is to be faithful. And that’s what we’ve learned.
Henry Kaestner: We started a new program with the Faith Driven Investor podcast. We’re kind of doing a pilot on it. It’s called Lightning Round, where we go through, and we asked our guests a series of questions maybe proceeding from easy to hard. But we want to try that with your new game.
Robert Netzly: I’m game. I mean, do I win a prize or something? And I do? Well, that’s big
Luke Roush: prize for those. We’re in and out burgers and the children’s prize?
Henry Kaestner: Yes. All right. Number one, there’s been much talk about the fact that the next generation, the next generation is just much more conscious about what matters to them. And I’m thinking about this as a father of a 17 year old and 16 year old and a 20 year old. Big name and teen fashion is Hollister, you move the company to Hollister, California. Is that the pander to this next generation of new investors
Robert Netzly: and move the company away from Hollister, California? To be clear, so we started the company in Hollywood, California, which has no relation to the clothing brand other than enterprising high school students selling their Hollister phys ed. You know the thing about $15 for $75 on eBay? So that’s the limit of the connection there. OK.
Henry Kaestner: So I was hoping it was more so for us. It was just brilliant marketing. You’re a fourth grade teacher. Give us one quick story 30 seconds or less about your favorite interaction with a fourth grader.
Robert Netzly: Yeah, I was almost the fourth grade teacher. Again, not to correct the host of the show twice in a row, but I went to school with the fourth grade teacher and I was this close. I did guest teaching during college before I dropped out. But an interaction that sticks with making those sort of student teaching things was clear. Today there is this little fourth grader named Paul in California, whereas doing my student teaching and there’s a little school garden. We went out there and we were pulling weeds in the school garden and this little kid, you could tell he just didn’t come for the best family. He had behavior issues. I was sort of assigned to sit with him like in the class because, you know, the teachers like, you just deal with this and that’s, you know, if you can deal with this kid like, great, thank you. So I can teach the other ones. But me and Paul just like, hit it off and I like I started saying, Do look at that, we you just that’s a huge weed. You are like a championship weed puller, Paul. And he just his eyes got big and he was pulling more weeds faster with more enthusiasm. Many other kids in that playground would bring every single one of them show me so I could like, give him an attaboy, Paul. And it just was so great. Is it a delight to me to see you when you encourage people?
Henry Kaestner: I imagine that translates into role as being a manager. Yeah, right? Because I’m not going to let the hostage thing go. I visited you in your office. It was on Main Street in Hollister, right?
Robert Netzly: No, we moved it from there. We started it there and we moved it. Now we’re in Boise, Idaho, so.
Henry Kaestner: Oh my goodness, I didn’t. Yeah.
Robert Netzly: Yeah, we moved. We escape California and are here. So we moved here in 2020. Super happy. We still have an office in California. I just we love our people there and it is a great community and
Henry Kaestner: you did teach fourth graders OK and I did. Yeah. Aside from your interaction with Chevron, what’s your favorite interaction you’ve had with a company in your role at Inspire?
Robert Netzly: That’s a hard one. I had some good ones. One company that will remain nameless, so I don’t throw them under the bus, but it was a different sort of conversation. It’s a major military contractor, major military contractor, and we called them because they had seemingly started moving towards endorsing, like LGBT activists, sort of legislations and policies that were also discriminatory against people of faith and things of that nature. And so we were just ERG. So I ended up having a conversation with the CFO. And after a few minutes of sort of getting to know each other, he’s feeling me on the phone. He realizes this is a safe space. He opens up and says, You know, I just got to be honest. I go to the Calvary Chapel in the next town over on a Christian. I love Jesus. I resonate with the things that you’re telling me right now and your concerns. But here’s my problem. I’m the CFO of this major military contractor, Fortune 500 company. I sit on the board, obviously, and we are just getting hammered by this really militant group that wants to push this particular agenda and push us in this direction. And I don’t know what to say, but I can’t just say, you know, I’m a Christian. I don’t believe in this stuff. I don’t want to support it. Like that would be suicide and wouldn’t be effective anyway. But he said, Thank you for calling and sharing your perspective because now what I can say in the boardroom is, you know, actually, I just had a conversation with this. Group of investors represent faith based investors all over the globe who see this issue in a different way. And so now I have some counter pressure that I can just say, Hey, you know, we need to serve all of our shareholders. Let’s just do our business and let’s stay out of the social politics arena and just do a good job for our shareholders and make good products that help our troops and everything else stick to the plan. And so it gave him something to, you know, to bring to the meeting. So I thought that was really cool, that we could have that effect.
Luke Roush: All right. I’ve got my three verses. You’re an early adopter in biblically responsible investing, and yet, you know, 10 years in or 15 or 20 years and you look at sort of the percentage of assets within kind of faith driven institutions that are managed in kind of a traditional British manner. And it’s still it’s really early. How do you walk alongside, you know, other investors that maybe kind of either on a different glide path towards a different way of doing what they do or maybe have different views? You know, I’ll always remember this time when Henry and I were in Texas talking about, you know, we kind of avoid alcohol, firearms, adult entertainment, all these things. I said, let’s go back to those firearms for a moment. And so there’s different. People who kind of see things differently, a couple that issues that we should all be able to agree on as believers. But then there’s also some kind of different perspectives, maybe just kind of walk us through and it’s maybe more than a 30 second answer, but walk us through how you have engaged with others in your own journey and then translated that to the journey that there are.
Robert Netzly: It’s a good question. And for us, as an asset manager who you know, you buy one of our funds, we can’t customize this fund for people, right? And so what we found is that having a standard approach to how we’re screening on the screens, we just screen out the same things for everybody. And we don’t do the whole custom screening thing. What we found is if you ask a client what’s important to you, I’m going to customize your screens. Usually it wraps around an . They don’t know how to think about that. And it just kind of it’s not a really positive conversation and it sort of stands out. So instead, we’re just like, what? Here’s the screens and we take the approach where we want to defer to our brothers and sisters who, you know, don’t have a problem with alcohol. I’ll drink a beer with you, right? But I understand I’ve got brothers and sisters who have alcoholism in their personal history. Maybe they’re had an abusive parent or something, and they don’t want to have anything to do with that. So we keep alcohol out of the portfolio. I’m a gun owner. I live in Idaho, you know? But I understand the other side of those issues. And so we add deference to our brothers and sisters. We screen out more than just sort of what, you know, our own personal conscience or whatever else may lead us onto. And what we found is a sort of counterintuitive that the people who care about those issues are absolutely grateful. It allows them to invest with a good conscience in your product. The people that were like, well, alcohol and I don’t really care about it. Well, it’s not like they want to invest in Budweiser specifically, and they’re not going to invest with you because you don’t own Budweiser. It’s just not really important to them. So as long as you can deliver a good product, the more you screen out, the more people you will actually attract and be able to serve is what we have found, and we see people having challenges and they try to water that down or sort of find a middle road. You end up not appealing to anybody.
Luke Roush: What’s something that you see differently than the rest of the world, but they would disagree with you?
Robert Netzly: Yeah. Well, I mean, as far as like the world in general, secular terms of the world, obviously lots of things we see differently. The whole approach to the ESG conversation, you could start with that. You know, we see that differently, both within the faith community and within the secular community. We’re a little bit of a pariah in both of those categories, sometimes because in very conservative Christian circles, ESG is, you know, synonymous with, well, progressive liberal. And they think, well, you know, ESG is evil. On the other side of the equation, you know, ESG does mean, well, the liberal progressive. And we’re not that. And so like, who are you guys to say that you’re is ERG like, you’re not like us, you can’t believe the Bible of Jesus and also see your ESG. So that’s a big differentiator. I think it just makes sense. The Bible tells us to take care of the planet. It doesn’t mean that we can’t pump out of oil out of the ground, but we should do it in a responsible way. Right. We shouldn’t just rape the planet, you know, indiscriminately. We should care for the stewardship of the planet does say how we should care for society people. You know, abortion is wrong. We shouldn’t do that. Those are social issues that are not, you know, the progressive ESG style and governance, corporate governance. Yeah, if the executives are stealing from the company, that’s wrong. If they’re bribing politicians, they shouldn’t do that. So having a truly faith based biblical worldview on ESG and using that terminology, I think is important for a number of reasons, but sometimes causes us to need to explain, you know, on both sides of the equation, you know what that actually means.
Luke Roush: What’s the new discovery? Since you remove the Boycie, you appreciate the most? And what’s the thing that you miss the most about Hollister
Robert Netzly: new discoveries in Idaho, Ben? Just freedom and just leave it at that in a lot of ways. I do miss. There’s just so much in California in general. I mean, you can drive to the beach and then later you can be in the mountains and you can be in the redwoods and it’s all around there, right? And it really is a special place. Just the diverse topography here. Here you’ve got mountains, you’ve got sagebrush, you’ve got topography, but it’s not quite the same. So I’d say I miss that. I was also, I’ll say I’ve been surprised to find that there’s phenomenal coffee shops and exquisite cuisine, including sushi. I had the best sushi in Boise, Idaho. We’re going to have anywhere else in the world. Come on, come on. There is some really good restaurants here and the coffee shops are like and is better in San Francisco or Santa Cruz or any of those other places. I challenge you to that test. That is absolutely true.
Henry Kaestner: All right. So I think you did well. I think you’re around 30 seconds, maybe forty five. But I thought the answers were awesome. We’re going to go back to a tried and true question that we’ve asked every guest across the Faith Driven Entrepreneur podcast and Faith Driven Investor podcast, and that’s something that you’re hearing. From God’s word, maybe it’s today, maybe it’s over the course of last week, but how is God speaking to you through the Bible?
Robert Netzly: Well, just recently, and this is related to the business where Jesus is really criticizing the Pharisees about use of the analogy that it’s like a cup this washed on the outside, but inside it’s all filthy and they’re just caring about the outside. But the inside is dirty. You know, there’s a lot of applications in our personal lives. We don’t want to look nice and shiny, but that our personal life is a wreck in our thought. Life is a wreck. And I’ve just been convicted that as the Supreme Court is looking at, you know, potentially rolling back Roe v. Wade and broadly expected, you know, ruling that just recently, I was given a statement from one of the most outspoken advocates for pro-life issues huge ministry, $200 million or some endowment. They own five stocks and companies that are manufacturing abortion drugs. Obviously some intentional, but it’s there and it’s across the Christian landscape. And so, you know, as we’re praying for an end to abortion, how can we not also be investing for an end to an abortion? So we really need to, you know, not just have a nice looking portfolio in terms of returns, risk adjusted or anything, but inside we’ve got to clean that up and things like abortion drugs do not belong, you know, in a portfolio like that. So that’s the stuff that’s been on my heart and God’s grace will we’ll get there?
Henry Kaestner: So you have been called the best dressed man in the world of faith driven investing. So that has nothing. So that passage in Matthew that you refer to presumably has nothing to do with you.
Robert Netzly: I hope not. But yes, in some sense, of course, my cup inside needs to be washed daily so that you’re
Henry Kaestner: not refuting the fact that you’re the best dressed man in Faith Driven
Robert Netzly: Investor. Well, I’m not saying that either. I don’t know anything.
Henry Kaestner: It’s awesome seeing you again. I’m sorry to have not known that you believed. I mourn the loss of another great, committed Christ follower that’s serious about faith and investing in this fine city, California. We’ve lost two great ones over the last two years, Luke and now Robert nicely. But I’m grateful for you. Spend the time and in via Zoom and and share with us.
Robert Netzly: It is my honor. Thank you guys for having me.
Episode 105 – Investing in Partnerships with Johan du Preez
Subscribe to the Podcast:







Johan du Preez’s career is defined by ambitious initiatives and big results. He says,“Capital always has an agenda. Whether by design or default, explicit or subtle, positive or negative, the application of capital facilitates and drives a bigger agenda.” Find out how this philosophy guides him to invest in partnerships that benefit the Kingdom, not just the marketplace.
All opinions expressed on this podcast, including the team and guests, are solely their opinions. Host and guests may maintain positions in the companies and securities discussed. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as specific investment advice for any individual or organization.
Episode Transcript
Transcription is done by an AI software. While technology is an incredible tool to automate this process, there will be misspellings and typos that might accompany it. Please keep that in mind as you work through it.
Henry Kaestner: Welcome back to Faith Driven Investor, it is awesome to be back here with Luke, my great friend who has abandoned me, has moved to Nashville and some really great guests that we’ve got today, Luke. It’s good to be back in the saddle has been a little while since we recorded a podcast and it’s good to be back with you, brother. It is good
Luke Roush: to be back and it’s good to be here with old friends.
Henry Kaestner: So indeed. And so today is another one of those special editions. You know, I talk about this all the time as we meet this great special edition. And indeed, today is just that. I love you one for many reasons. Just got a great heart for the Lord. But I also love the way that we’ve been able to challenge and encourage each other over the course of the last four or five years as we’ve gotten to know each other better. I can’t remember when I originally met Johan, but when I did meet Johan, I really felt like I met this kindred soul, a guy who had been an operator who is now an investor who was really just leaning into his faith and trying to understand how he might honor God. But he was doing it, not in Silicon Valley, where I live, or Nashville, where Luke is or some of the other locations he was joining in South Africa. And I was just fascinated by that. And as Luke and I were talking about expanding the work of Faith Driven Investor to highlight fund managers people that were serious about their faith and who wanted to have spiritual integration and how they invested with excellence, I could think of no better story than Johan. And so as we get ready shortly to launch the African version of Faith Driven Entrepreneur and investor, we’re going to do Faith Driven Entrepreneur Africa. We want to spend a lot more time focusing on the continent of Africa. We want to change the narrative a bit to help people understand the opportunities that are there. I don’t know what your preconceived notion might be of Africa. Maybe it is one of great opportunity in a marketplace that is thriving and it’s young and it’s vibrant. But we’re going to try to scope that out over the course of this year periodically by visiting Africa like we are today to understand what’s going on in the marketplace in a way that hopefully you, the listener, might feel encouraged to participate, or at least pray about how you might be involved. So without further ado, Johan, thank you very much for being with us.
Johan du Preez: Great to be here. Thanks. And they always encouraged by this information.
Henry Kaestner: Thank you. So we’d like to do this, of course, with all of our guests. And we actually this is a special edition because not only do we have Johan, our great friend and fund manager, but we’ve actually asked one of his portfolio companies Job Jack Christian, to come on board as well, to talk a little bit about what it looks like to have a fund that invest and the relationship that a fund manager can have with a portfolio company. And ultimately, what happens on the ground? What is it the job Jack does? And then what does that relationship look like between the entrepreneur and the investor? So, Christian, welcome to we’re looking forward to hear more from you at the end of the program, but glad you’re here. Welcome.
Christian van den Berg: Thanks so much, Jan. Super blessed to be a part of this conversation.
Henry Kaestner: Awesome. Thank you, brother. OK, Johan. Who are you? Where do you come from?
Johan du Preez: Hey. So I was born in rural South Africa. Very small, actually on a farm closes town, probably 10 miles away. Great place to have an upbringing, I must say. My first recollection from my family were that they were glad to see me, that they liked me, and they probably believed I was going to do something good in life. So I never actually realized how big a blessing that was until later in my life. Yeah, so I grew up there, dad. Good business guy. One word for him would be integrity. You always wanted to do the right thing. Always did the right thing. Passed away about 20 years ago, but my mother is still alive and she’s a woman of prayer, so she prayed for us as children. She’s praying for us today. She’s praying for this business today and for our investee companies. So that’s just a brilliant privilege to have.
Henry Kaestner: Christian, did you know that we’re going off script here? Did you know that Johan’s mother is praying for you?
Christian van den Berg: John, as mentioned it every now and and I just feel it in my spirit. So, you know, when you get that deal, it’s all right.
Henry Kaestner: So when we’re finished with this podcast, I’m calling my mom, OK. Let’s go back to the story, Johan, please. By the way, when you’re growing up on a farm in South Africa, is this one where you might be visited by wild animals?
Johan du Preez: No, not quite. So I can claim that one. But yeah, it was pretty rural, also the primary school. So we don’t have middle school road. We have primary school high school in South Africa. The primary school that I was in, grade one to seven would have one hundred and eighty pupils in total, so we were like seven boys in a grade. So needless to say, you were pretty good at everything, right? You were an athlete, you were a leader, you were whatnot. So that’s good for your self-esteem. So, yeah, that was rural and that was good. And then I went to Pretoria, which is a city in South Africa, to study pharmacy. Don’t quite know why I studied pharmacy, probably in the town that I live. That was the only professional guy I saw. You know, we did some business on the side as well, so pharmacy was good for me, though no one. I met my wife in pharmacy school, which was still, to this day, the best transaction of my life. I’ve done a few, but that was the best one. I guess I’ll do another few years of organic chemistry to get that privilege. But it also paved the way for me to get to the US, ultimately, which I didn’t foresee because I developed a shortage of pharmacists in the US at some point and they were recruiting internationally. So that would pave that way for us there.
Henry Kaestner: Okay, so Johan, you’re based in South Africa. And in the intro, I talked a little bit about how unique that is. And there are folks who are having a mental picture here of what South Africa is like, but you not only know it well, you also know the United States really well. So you’ve spent enough time in America and being an operator to have a perspective of what business looks like in America and what it looks like in South Africa. What are some misconceptions that people might have about what commerce looks like in the marketplace looks like in South Africa and does share a little bit about the landscape you’re seeing?
Johan du Preez: OK? South Africa is an incredible country, as you well know, having visited here and before I get into the investing side just to say the people, I just love the people of Africa. I mean, people have real servant hearts. That’s probably our number one asset. You know, you think about different countries like Israel being well known for inventing stuff like the US being having that gift of commercialization. And you think of Africa and people really have a heart to serve, which of course, have been misused over the years as well. But it’s a great asset. I think from a misconception perception, you know, you have a first world infrastructure in South Africa, you have an excellent banking system. From a technology perspective, I would say superior to the US because we started later. So it’s more mobile friendly and just advanced. The regulatory framework is excellent. Good central bank, good markets, very liquid markets. That’s why our currency tends to fluctuate quite a bit because it trades so well. That’s on the one hand. But then on the other hand, you still have a bit of a regulatory arbitrage in terms of not, you know, it’s not that difficult. You don’t have to have five licenses to operate, one business type of thing. You know, you still have a bit of room to move in. You can still do a lot with a little bit of capital. So that’s the beauty of it in terms of significance on the African continent. Number three, in terms of GDP after Nigeria and Egypt, and number four in terms of GDP per capita. So it has huge influence on the continent, although it’s only 5.5 million people. But we have a fair amount of challenges. We sitting with an unemployment rate of about 30 percent with the GDP of it, was just forty six percent a few years ago. Now we’re sitting at 70 and heading for 19 three years from now. And that is a consequence of really a period where we had a corrupt president between 2009 and 2018. So great country all together. People probably underestimate the infrastructure, but if they think about Africa and they have a mental picture about South Africa,
Henry Kaestner: OK, that’s good. OK, so before we go on, I just want to make sure that we share with our audience these two funds you run. Can you just describe what Saad is and what Tree of Life is, please?
Johan du Preez: Yes. So coming out of the first half of my career, which was as an operator and a turnaround CEO, then when God stopped and called me out run about 2006, I wasn’t exactly sure what I should do. But I understood that it was about capital and I understood that it was about not owning it and just hitting it. So essentially created two entities a not-for-profit entity called the Tree of Life Foundation, which is a classic nonprofit. But that entity owns 100 per cent of a cutting edge investment company called Solid Investment Holdings, where we do investments, where we had a fund manager with a vision to actually be like an investment bank one day a significant player in South Africa in the financial services field. We call it the Hobby Lobby or the Chick-Fil-A of financial services. That’s the way we’re going. Although at the moment we are focusing primarily on private equity.
Luke Roush: So one of the things that was really clear on from the first time that you and I met and I believe we originally met through Christian Economic Forum, but you are a relational person, and it’s true, I think globally that relationships matter in terms of how we invest. But as you just think about your own work as an investor and some of the relationships that you’ve cultivated over. Years, you know, maybe just give us some observations in terms of what you look for in those kind of partnerships, in those relationships.
Johan du Preez: Right? So look, I mean, that’s spot on. I think we all deal with relationships all the time, but you can never over emphasize the importance of that. In fact, I didn’t actually have a clue. You know what Tree of Life meant when I named the foundation Tree of Life? And then because God just gave me that name, and then years later, I said to the pastor friend, and he explained to me the difference between the three of knowledge of good and evil and the tree of Life being a relationship with God rather than a contractual and transactional one, rather than a knowledge of good and evil being a father son relationship. So it’s the foundation of what we do in terms of business first. All of the investee companies, but then also with co-investors, with ministries locally that we fund. I over the years have learned, you know, if someone doesn’t have an ego, if they are willing to objectively look at themselves, if they don’t see others as role players in their movie, but they have an outward mindset of seeing the bigger picture, then you know, you can go a long way with people like that. And it’s one of the main criteria we look at when we invest is not only whether this would be successful or not, whether this would be a partner, that we can walk along the road we have that we can learn from. But then we can also sometimes share some knowledge with and they will objectively consider that.
Luke Roush: So that’s helpful. And you know, I love the Paul Christian in here as well just to get his take. But you know, different ways to think about relationships and kind of building community. Some people do it, you know, based on proximity. Some people do it based on, you know, similar interests or different causes that you’re drawn to together. Others do it in a way that’s very tied into their church or to their faith. Any observations Christian from you in terms of what you’ve seen work well, what you want to do more of maybe what you want to do less of?
Christian van den Berg: Yes. So thanks for the question. I mean, you know, speaking of the father son relationship, you know, outlook and we’ve really come to appreciate that in English, it’s not, you know, not coming to us for the country. You know, I’ll take that really coming for the relationship behind it, for the discipleship behind it. And I think once you can put away those monetary politics, it’s so beautiful to be able to move freely in a space where, you know, going for mentorship, where you’re receiving feedback, choosing to accept that feedback or not. And so it’s really been super liberating space to operate in. Does that make sense?
Luke Roush: Yeah, it’s great. And maybe speak just a little bit on the on the length of time that you know, folks before you choose to partner with them.
Johan du Preez: So I think they also Praxis of could shorten their time. So I mean, oftentimes it would be great to know them for three years or so. But like, for instance, with Christian, I think our relationship via Traeger, which is the South African version of Praxis, you know, that’s just shortcuts, because by the time someone has decided to take a year and enroll in a tree, pay good money to do that, but also that they want that in their lives. You know, if you meet someone in that type of forum, I think, you know, you don’t need the same amount of time elapsed before you actually know them really well.
Henry Kaestner: So I want to go back to Christian for a second and Christian. You’ve got a company called Job Jack. So what is Job Jack? And then you also mentioned Trigger two, and maybe you can explain to us what triggers an organization that I’ve gotten to know well and admire a lot. But I’d love to hear about it through your lens. So why don’t you give us like a little bit of a flyover about how you got into trigger, what trigger did and then what job Jack does?
Christian van den Berg: Yeah, cool. Awesome trigger. I mean, I was a little reluctant when I heard of another accelerator. It’s the buzzword for tech startups. But so what triggered is it’s this amazing organization with the heart behind redemptive business to call entrepreneurs, to cool business people that have received the vision, whether they know it from the Lord or not, and to realign them into seeing what is the redemptive purpose behind why God is giving them that vision for that specific business. And so it’s just accelerated. That takes a group of 18 to 20 entrepreneurs for profit and nonprofit and leads them in a space of a year with a few gatherings. That includes, I think, 40 mentors that have dedicated their time to really come and showcase life’s lessons and what God’s taught them as well. And so it’s just incredible space where relationship is both in building business together, but also respecting what God’s called each individual to do. And so that was an amazing blessing for us to be really opened our eyes into the differentiating factors between what we believe is your typical sort of pop and reasoning for growth as opposed to, you know, why God’s called us to do something. Yeah, it’s just it opened our eyes as founders, microfinance myself, but also we could relate that to our employees and to why we’re doing what we’re doing. To have that his base behind each decision and drug, Jack, as you go, Jack is a sort of tech start up company that focuses on automating entry level recruitment. So our hardest to see the world, the employed, we’ve noticed that there’s a massive gap between your lower skilled type of jobs, jobs that don’t require qualifications above high school, where there’s a load of money being spent and wasted for job seekers that have to print out paper CVS and take public transport to try and find jobs. John alluded to it earlier, so unemployment rate in South Africa is bordering between 30 and 40 per cent. And if you include people that are despondent that on issue, even looking for work, it’s close to 50 per cent. And so with this, this massive disconnect and loss of hope, we’ve come to see how we can remove those areas to access for opportunities for a market that has been overlooked from a technology perspective and to see how we can facilitate the marriage between employers, large employers in South Africa or small and large and the very living jobseekers that are looking for those opportunities. So we’ve made it legal for any data free for these types of jobseekers to get profiles and to get connected to a relevant job opportunities. And on your company’s site to automate the entire process for them so that they’re not struggling to find someone relevant. And you can place someone in a sustainable opportunity so that they can then look after their families and kind of the economy can grow from that point on.
Henry Kaestner: So my life as an investor, I like to look at deals from both the bottom up and top down if I can. And you spoke a lot to the bottom up. And Johan, I think I chose you very, very well for the program. And I love the trigger conference. When you get a young man or young woman who’s so captivated by this sense of being able to make a redemptive product or service and just having faith be such a part of their life and their work. But there’s also a top down element. This really intrigued me too, is, as I’ve heard, there are going to be more entrants into the job market in Africa over the course of next 20 years. And I think India and China. I mean, so it’s a it’s a big opportunity that’s really growing. And so you’ve got this redemptive service aspect of what you’re doing, but you’re also in this massively growing market. Johan, I’m wondering if you could speak and just give us some more illustrations of some of the opportunities you see for, say, Western investors or non-African investors that are looking to participate in Africa and have thought their, gosh, you know, African investments. It’s just it’s another fair trade coffee deal, right, that I’m going to go ahead and we get bags of and I’m going to sell at church. There’s something completely different that you’re looking at. Give us a flyover about how you look at Africa, how you look at opportunities. What are the top down opportunities you see?
Johan du Preez: I think capital is scarce in Africa, specifically capital in certain pockets. So if we just talk about the investment landscape in South Africa for a moment and again, you know, the equity markets are really well structured and operate well. The big private equity funds operate well, listings, mergers, the listings, all of that stuff. But as soon as you get to a market capitalization of 20 million U.S. dollars and below, there’s just a scarcity of capital. And the reason for that is also because you need some non-financial investment to unlock the financial capital. You know, these are typical entrepreneurs that have done something right and they are building a great business, but now they’re running into those type of things that they’ve never seen before. You know, they’ve never put together an executive leadership team. They’ve never registered a patent. They’ve never had to think about how to structure the balance sheet for growth. They don’t know a corporate banker. They haven’t made a good merger lawyer. So I think you know where we see the great opportunities that actually come alongside those entrepreneurs and help them before you get to is different industries just generically in terms of size of the company. That’s where the jobs are being created. That’s what could change the country as well. But it is from a pure commercial investment management business perspective. It is messy. It’s not as scalable as just investing capital and getting some reports. Every quarter of how the company is doing. It means seeing companies on a monthly basis, being there for them, rolling up your sleeves a bit. So I think that probably is a little bit different from the first world because we don’t have the same level of social capital. Many of the entrepreneurs didn’t grow up in a family where the dad was speaking about business at the dinner table, and that is where I see the biggest void.
Luke Roush: Mm hmm. So maybe just in terms of that context, recognizing that you have capital that you’re providing to folks who kind of have a dream or a vision of how they’re going to change society, how do you try to get to the answer of your ability to bring value beyond stroking a check, which is something that you know, makes a ton of sense to me? So we don’t just want to be seen as a capital source, we want to be seen as. Someone who can really pour into other aspects of the business beyond just financial needs. And yet sometimes it’s hard to unpack that when you are the one that’s actually writing the check. Maybe just speak a little bit to how you approach that in terms of process in an African context.
Johan du Preez: I think, look, the first common sense thing to do is to not invest where you cannot add value beyond capital, right? So really, to be honest with yourself as well, when you look at a company and realize, do we have what it takes to make a difference in this company? That’s the first thing. The second thing is that you guys do so well at Faith Driven Athlete mean, you think about it as a movement and not an organization, right? And if you have the mindset of a movement rather than an organization, then don’t try and just find everything in your company. We just did a retail investment enough last year. Go look and see that none of us have deep retail experience. Look for someone that she is your values. We found the ex financial director of a listed retail group have him co-invest with us and bring that benefit to the company that you’re investing in. So looking then we as a country want to help you, not just we as a company and help those entrepreneurs find people in the economy that they wouldn’t normally have access to to come and help with that.
Henry Kaestner: Are you on you talk about this concept of co-investing with people who are experts in an industry and look at my investment experience that’s been really successful as we’ve looked in investing in foreign markets. I think especially in Indonesia, having local co-investors was really important. But then having people who have specific industry knowledge in on the deal with you seems to make a lot of sense. Is that something you look for in most of your investments? Just talk us through that a little bit.
Johan du Preez: Yeah, for sure. I think we have as we have a wide experience in the financial services industry. So for most of that, we have it within our closed network in terms of board members, in terms of employees and all of that. But as soon as we go outside of that, our default mindset is actually to look for people that’s going to help. And I’ve just been amazed at how willing people are, especially people that may be retired, have sold the business and they are very keen to give back, but also at another level, sometimes just with a due diligence. You know, I’ve had asset managers just give me and analysts. The bank analysts had a company to give me their bank analyst for a week or two just to help us on the due diligence. People actually want to make a difference. And you must just create the opportunity for them to make a difference. So I think to answer your question, that’s our default mindset is that we actually expect someone out there that’s going to be able to help us and that we’ll do a better job than we can and we must find him or her.
Luke Roush: You have to understand just your basic philosophy of investing and how you approach capital markets in putting capital to work.
Johan du Preez: So we think about capital a lot. You may have heard that we say capital always has an agenda. It’s we like to make things simple for ourselves and for us. Capital always has an agenda, and our biggest job is to make sure that that agenda is Christ. So if you think about capital in the application, that all of it facilitates a lot of things. And if you think about capital markets or financial services markets, it really helps you to achieve something with your capital that you wouldn’t have really been able to do on your own. But by coming along with other people that have the same agenda, you can achieve that. And that could be as simple as you want the 20 per cent IRR, but it may be as complicated as you want to change the world, and you may not be able to build an airport on your own. But if you join an infrastructure funds, just sure enough you can build an airport. You cannot insure your own health risk. But if enough people can join the pool, then between you, you can ensure each other. So for us, the notion of collective capital leaving behind a common purpose is just so attractive and such a no brainer for the Christian community as well to come along and say, Let’s pool our like minded capital. For us, the sweet spot is really donor advised fund capital for that reason, because someone has already decided that they want to set aside this capital, that this capital is not going to be for them in their family. This capital needs to make a difference of some sort. And then you find that about 80 percent of what we manage is donor advised fund capital. The expectation for excellence is no less. The competence requirement is nothing less than what you would expect in a cutting edge private capital business. But the outcome is somehow different because whatever we can generate in returns, whatever impact we can have on an investment is in that realm of the like minded. Set aside capital and maybe briefly, if I may, you know, we see a few themes emerging as we thought experiment. With this type of capital, you find this thought up like Christiane, this is this is a business. This is a great idea, but I know the author of this idea is God, and I want to honor him in this business and I need access to capital. But I don’t want capital with another agenda, someone that’s just going to set the speed of my treadmill and, you know, doesn’t want to hear about our purpose. So start ups, you see that early stage companies, you see it often in replacement capital to Christian brothers sort of business. It’s all guns blazing and no one wants to retire now he or she wants to get fair commercial reward for what they’ve built. At the same time, they don’t want to compromise, you know, on what they allow into the business. So, you know, that is really important. And I think to step into the shoes of that exiting shareholder, the most recent transaction we’ve done is a 74 year old gentleman who wants to go on and run this business until he’s 90, but just in case something happens, which he sees as very unlikely. You know, he needs some other shareholders that can step in to that shareholders shoes of his. He’s got the succession planning in the business, but he doesn’t have the shareholder succession. But he’s all about culture, all about Christian ethos. And it was so just so great to do a transaction with him where we buy 30 per cent, but we can also take up the risk over time. And he has peace of mind, but he can continue to run with it.
Luke Roush: So, yeah, as powerful, you know, I love that. And you know, we talk sometimes about the capital markets and the cycles that businesses go through are oftentimes more of a relay race than they are an individual race. And so there’s times when you know individuals need to be able to pass the baton to someone else who hopefully has alignment, not just in terms of the potential for the business, but also in alignment around the values and the culture that underpins much of the business of success. So I really appreciate you sharing that powerful Christian.
Henry Kaestner: Did you have any save rounds?
Christian van den Berg: Yes. So I think something that I’d really like to emphasize the value. And John spoke about capital having an agenda, the value of having your first large investors having a kingdom mindset has been so crucial because it’s the first time you have possibly someone else sitting on your board, you know, another director that’s already a tough transition for anyone. And now you’ve got someone that shares that like mindedness that can keep you accountable to why you’re doing what you’re doing because things get sticky on a good month on a bad month. The first thing we have a discussion about when we walk into a board meeting is not how’s the business going? I’m proud of you because you’ve made money or I’m disappointed because you’ve lost my money. How’s it going with your family? Are you putting them first? How’s it going with your relationship with the Lord or you’re putting him first? And I think moving into a growing business, it’s so key to have someone from the outside that if walked the hard yards, really be able to keep you accountable in that. And as we start taking on new investors, that’s formed our base. And so it’s immovable, established in God’s ways as a do.
Henry Kaestner: That was really good. That’s really good. I’m really glad we asked. I’m really glad you answered.
Luke Roush: You know, one of the things we like to do on Christian is just cause each episode by hearing what God is teaching you right now. So what are you found in God’s word that has stuck out to you recently? And how does that maybe impact the work that you’re doing day to day so above for both of you to take a cut at that one?
Johan du Preez: So I’m in business and otherwise I go narrow and deep rather than wide. So, you know, that is helping business with focus. It has its downsides as well. So I’m stuck in the Book of James this year so far, and I think I’m going to be there for probably a few months more. And what just strikes me and challenges me about James and that book is about the conversion of a belief system into real practical deeds, the outward mindset, again, that we spoke about earlier and the dependency on the wisdom that we receive from God and the humility that we need in order to unlock that flow of wisdom. So there’s a bunch more in that book, but those are probably the highlights this fall for me, and I’ll have a few more in a couple of months.
Luke Roush: That’s good. Christian, how about for you?
Christian van den Berg: Yes. So I think something that’s hit me quite hard in the past few months is that the tough decision making when it comes to business, I’m still quite young. Twenty eight, and you get faced with quite a few tough decisions, whether it be having to let someone go or having to make the tough financial decision. And what really struck me, especially with the wisdom and the discipleship that we’ve received, is that because God’s given us this mission, it’s ours to steward and it’s our steward excellently. And so if I can approach every day with that mindset as to this is not mine to mess up or mine to again, for myself, it’s mine. Just do it for the Lord. It just makes this decision so much easier to operate in freedom and in wisdom instead of guilt and frustration. And so still practicing with the application of it, but it’s been super liberating to. Richard, that mindset as well.
Luke Roush: Well, I love that and you know, there’s a narrative at times kind of within this intersection of faith and work that that somehow kind of alleviates or makes it too that you don’t have to make difficult choices. But you know, the reality is when you’re leading an organization, as you said, stewarding an organization, you’ve got to be able to make difficult decisions for the health of the organization in the mission. And so what really comes first is not necessarily individual people, but the mission. And sometimes that means hard conversation. So I appreciate you sharing on that.
Henry Kaestner: Christian, Johann, Christian, it’s great to have you guys on board. Thank you for helping us to understand your investment philosophy, what it’s like to invest in South Africa. Hopefully, our listeners have a little bit of a different perspective. Hopefully they’ve heard some things, whether it’s about thinking about co-investors or just top down versus bottom up. And then just just a vision into what it looks like to have this relationship between the entrepreneur and the investor, which I think is really, really key. And what I heard from Christian and picked up from him is that he’s grateful that you’re involved in his company. And I’m grateful you’re both involved in our podcast. So thank you.
Johan du Preez: Thank you very much.
Christian van den Berg: Thanks so much.
Recent Posts
- Episode 220 – Why Charity Alone Can Never Solve The World’s Greatest Problems
- Episode 219 – The Eternal ROI No Investor Should Miss | Randy Alcorn
- Episode 218 – Marks on the Market: Iran, AI, and a Dynamic Market Environment | Brian McClard & Matt Monson
- Episode 217 – How Kingdom Advisors is Shaping The Future of Faith-Driven Finance | Rob West
- Episode 216 – Marks on the Market: America’s Push to Reshore U.S. Manufacturing | Steve Cook (LFM Capital)